Skip to content

Chemistry · Ch 3 — Haloalkanes and Haloarenes

Stability of Carbocations

3.7

Stability of Carbocations

A carbocation is a carbon bearing only three bonds and a formal positive charge, with an empty pp orbital; it is sp2sp^2-hybridised and planar at that carbon. Its relative stability governs how readily a haloalkane ionises in the rate-determining step of SN1S_N1 (and the closely related E1 elimination), since a more stable carbocation corresponds to a lower-energy transition state for its formation.

Order of stability from alkyl substitution: 3∘>2∘>1∘>methyl3^\circ > 2^\circ > 1^\circ > \text{methyl}. Each alkyl group attached to the cationic carbon stabilises the positive charge in two ways: hyperconjugation, in which a C–H\text{C--H} (or C–C\text{C--C}) sigma bond on an adjacent carbon partially overlaps with and donates electron density into the empty pp orbital (more adjacent bonds available means more hyperconjugative stabilisation, so more alkyl substitution helps), and the inductive effect, by which alkyl groups are weakly electron-donating relative to hydrogen and so partially offset the positive charge. A tertiary carbocation, flanked by three alkyl groups, therefore benefits from both effects the most and is the most stable of the simple alkyl cations; the methyl cation, with no adjacent carbon at all, is the least stable and essentially never forms under ordinary conditions.

Resonance stabilisation exceeds simple alkyl substitution. A carbocation adjacent to a π\pi system -- benzylic (next to an aromatic ring) or allylic (next to a C=C\text{C=C} double bond) -- is stabilised far more strongly than even a tertiary alkyl cation, because the positive charge can be delocalised by resonance over several atoms rather than merely offset inductively from adjacent bonds. …