Read the following extract carefully and answer the questions that follow : A mother's advice The Mahabharata

Question

Q. Read the following extract carefully and answer the questions that follow : A mother's advice The Mahabharata describes how, when war between the Kauravas and the Pandavas became inevitable, Gandhari made one last appeal to her eldest son Duryodhana : By making peace you honour your father and me, as well as your well-wishers ... it is the wise man in control of his senses who guards his kingdom. Greed and anger drag a man away from his profits; by defeating these two enemies a king conquers the earth ... You will happily enjoy the earth, my son, along with the wise and heroic Pandavas ... There is no good in a war, no law (dharma) and profit (artha), let alone happiness; nor is there (necessarily) victory in the end — don't set your mind on war ... Duryodhana did not listen to this advice and fought and lost the war. (13.1) Analyse Gandhari's concern for her eldest son, Duryodhana.

(2) (13.2) How do you think that greed and anger are the vices that overcome the senses of man ?

(2) (13.3) Explain the wise suggestion Gandhari gave to her son. (3)

CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2019Subjective· 7mImportance★★★★★

🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Concept understanding — Respect For Elders

Respect for Elders

You already know this feeling. When your grandmother tells you to sit down and eat, you sit. When your father's colleague visits, you greet them with namaste or a slight bow. When an older cousin gives you advice about college, you listen — even if you don't follow it. That instinct to pause, to defer, to acknowledge someone who has lived longer than you — that is the seed of respect for elders.

But in your textbooks, this concept goes much deeper than mere habit or custom.

What the NCERT Textbook Says

In the context of Indian society and culture — which you study in subjects like Sociology, Political Science, or Value Education — respect for elders is not just a personal virtue. It is a social norm that structures relationships, maintains continuity across generations, and preserves cultural knowledge.

The NCERT class XI Sociology textbook (Understanding Society) discusses how traditional societies rely on age-based hierarchies to transmit values. Elders are seen as repositories of experience. They have witnessed more cycles of life — more harvests, more festivals, more births and deaths — and therefore possess a kind of wisdom that cannot be learned from books alone.

Important

In Indian social thought, respect for elders is not about blind obedience. It is about acknowledging the moral authority that comes from lived experience. The elder is not always right — but their perspective carries weight because they have seen more consequences unfold.

Why This Matters for a Commerce/Humanities Student

You might think: I'm studying business or law or economics — why does this matter?

Here is why. Every organisation, every market, every legal system is built on relationships. And relationships in India — whether in a family firm, a government office, or a corporate boardroom — are still shaped by this norm. A junior manager who dismisses a senior's advice without listening is seen as arrogant, not efficient. A politician who publicly disrespects an older leader loses credibility. A business deal often closes not on the contract alone, but on the trust built when the younger party shows deference.

Respect for elders is, in effect, a social lubricant that reduces friction in hierarchies. It allows knowledge to flow downward and authority to be accepted without constant conflict.

Key Dimensions (Bullet Points)

Cultural transmission: Elders pass down language, rituals, craft skills, and moral codes. Without this respect, each generation would have to reinvent everything from scratch.
Social stability: Age-based hierarchy creates predictable roles. Everyone knows who to consult for what kind of problem. This reduces chaos. …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Gandhari's appeal to Duryodhana reveals a mother's wisdom rooted in dharma: she warns that greed and anger destroy kingdoms, urges peace with the Pandavas, and reminds him that war brings neither righteousness nor lasting victory — advice he tragically ignored.

(13.1) Analyse Gandhari's concern for her eldest son, Duryodhana.

Gandhari's concern is layered with both maternal love and political wisdom. She is not simply a mother pleading for her son's safety; she is a queen who understands the catastrophic consequences of the impending war. Her appeal is framed around honour — she reminds Duryodhana that making peace would honour his parents and well-wishers, anchoring her argument in the deeply held value of respect for elders and duty to family.

At the same time, her words carry a pragmatic edge. She knows Duryodhana's character flaws — his greed for the throne and his anger toward the Pandavas — and she tries to redirect him toward self-control and wisdom. Her concern is not just for his life but for his legacy and the survival of the Kuru dynasty. She sees the war as avoidable and destructive, and her plea is a last attempt to save him from his own worst impulses.

Note

Gandhari's blindfolded life (she chose to share her husband Dhritarashtra's blindness) adds poignancy to her words — she "sees" the truth more clearly than her sighted son.

(13.2) How do you think that greed and anger are the vices that overcome the senses of man?

Gandhari identifies greed and anger as the twin enemies that "drag a man away from his profits" — meaning they cloud judgment and lead to self-destruction. Greed blinds a person to what is enough; it creates an insatiable hunger that makes even a kingdom seem insufficient. Duryodhana had half the kingdom after the division, yet his greed for absolute power made him refuse even five villages to the Pandavas.

Anger, on the other hand, distorts perception and fuels rash decisions. It overrides reason and wisdom, turning potential allies into enemies. Together, these vices create a toxic cycle: greed breeds resentment when desires are unmet, and anger justifies destructive actions to fulfill those desires. A man "in control of his senses" — as Gandhari puts it — is one who has mastered these impulses, allowing dharma and artha (righteousness and material well-being) to guide his actions instead.

In Duryodhana's case, his greed for the throne and his anger at the Pandavas' existence made him deaf to all counsel, including his mother's. The Mahabharata uses his downfall to illustrate how unchecked vices lead not just to personal ruin but to the destruction of entire lineages.

(13.3) Explain the wise suggestion Gandhari gave to her son.

Gandhari's suggestion rests on three interconnected pillars: peace, self-control, and shared prosperity.

First, she urges Duryodhana to make peace with the Pandavas, framing it not as surrender but as wisdom. She reminds him that he could "happily enjoy the earth" alongside his cousins, suggesting that coexistence and alliance are stronger than conquest. This reflects the Mahabharata's recurring theme that family unity and dharma are more valuable than territorial ambition. …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Same / Similar Concept — real previous-year questions on the same or a closely similar concept, not this exact question.

CBSE 2026Set 61/3/11 markMCQ
$Q. Identify the character from the Mahabharata with the help of the following information and choose the correct option : - He was the elder brother of Pandu. - He was the king of Hastinapur. - He was the husband of Gandhari. Options : (A) Dushasana (B) Duryodhana (C) Dhritarashtra (D) Dushkarna$
›Reveal solutionSolution

The character described is Dhritarashtra — the elder brother of Pandu, king of Hastinapur, and husband of Gandhari.

The Mahabharata is built around a family feud, and at the centre of that family stands a king who was born blind. That king is Dhritarashtra. The clues given in the question point directly to him, and each one is a key fact from the epic as recorded in the NCERT textbook.

First, the question says he was the elder brother of Pandu. In the Kuru dynasty, Vichitravirya died young, leaving two widows — Ambika and Ambalika. By the practice of niyoga (levirate), the sage Vyasa fathered children with them. Ambika gave birth to Dhritarashtra, and Ambalika gave birth to Pandu. So Dhritarashtra was indeed the elder brother, though he was born blind. Pandu, though younger, became king initially because a blind man could not rule according to the norms of the time.

Second, he was the king of Hastinapur. After Pandu renounced the throne and went to the forest, and later died, Dhritarashtra ruled as king. The NCERT text notes that Dhritarashtra was the father of the Kauravas and ruled from Hastinapur. His reign is the backdrop for the entire conflict of the Mahabharata.

Third, he was the husband of Gandhari. Gandhari is a central figure — she famously blindfolded herself for life to share her husband's blindness. The NCERT mentions her as the wife of Dhritarashtra and the mother of the Kauravas. …
Start your 14-day free trial to see the full solution →

Concept understanding — Respect For Elders

Respect for Elders

What the NCERT Textbook Says

Why This Matters for a Commerce/Humanities Student

Key Dimensions (Bullet Points)

A Mother's Advice: Gandhari and Duryodhana

13.1 Analyse Gandhari's concern for her eldest son, Duryodhana. (2)

13.2 How do you think that greed and anger are the vices that overcome the senses of man? (2)

13.3 Explain the wise suggestion Gandhari gave to her son. (3) …

(13.1) Analyse Gandhari's concern for her eldest son, Duryodhana.

(13.2) How do you think that greed and anger are the vices that overcome the senses of man?

(13.3) Explain the wise suggestion Gandhari gave to her son.

(13.1) Analyse Gandhari's concern for her eldest son, Duryodhana.

(13.2) How do you think that greed and anger are the vices that overcome the senses of man?

(13.3) Explain the wise suggestion Gandhari gave to her son.

🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days

Unlock everything free for 14 days