Skip to content
Question

Q.Read the following source and answer the questions that follow : (1+1+2=4) From the Fifth Report Referring to the condition of zamindars and the auction of lands, the Fifth Report stated : The revenue was not realised with punctuality, and lands to a considerable extent were periodically exposed to sale by auction. In the native year 1203, corresponding with 1796-97, the land advertised for sale comprehended a jumma or assessment of sicca rupees 28,70,061, the extent of land actually sold bore a jumma or assessment of rupees 14,18,756 and the amount of purchase money sicca rupees 17,90,416. In 1204, corresponding with 1797-98, the land advertised was for sicca rupees 26,66,191, the quantity sold was for sicca rupees 22,74,076, and the purchase money sicca rupees 21,47,580. Among the defaulters were some of the oldest families of the country. Such were the rajahs of Nuddea, Rajeshaye, Bishenpore (all districts of Bengal), ... and others, the dismemberment of whose estates at the end of each succeeding year, threatened them with poverty and ruin, and in some instances presented difficulties to the revenue officers, in their efforts to preserve undiminished the amount of public assessment. (33.1) Examine the reason for calling it as a 'Fifth Report'.

(1) (33.2) Why were activities of East India company closely debated in England ?
(1) (33.3) Analyse any two limitations of this report. (2)
CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2023Subjective· 4mImportance★★★★★
🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

The Fifth Report was a parliamentary document that exposed the devastating impact of the Permanent Settlement, especially the auctioning of zamindari estates, and revealed how the Company’s revenue policies were destroying old landed families in Bengal.

The passage you have been given comes from a document known as the Fifth Report, which was submitted to the British Parliament in 1813. To understand why it is called the “Fifth Report,” you need to know a bit about how the British Parliament supervised the East India Company. After the Regulating Act of 1773, the Company was required to periodically submit reports on its administration in India to the British government. The Fifth Report was the fifth in a series of such reports prepared by a Select Committee of the House of Commons. It was specifically concerned with the affairs of the Bengal Presidency, and it became famous because it contained a wealth of detailed, often critical, information about the Company’s revenue policies, judicial system, and the condition of the people under Company rule.

Note

The Fifth Report is not a single document written by one person. It is a massive compilation of evidence, letters, and official records gathered by the parliamentary committee. Its real value for historians is that it provides an insider’s view of how the Company’s administration actually worked — warts and all.

Now, let us turn to the second part of your question: why were the activities of the East India Company closely debated in England? The answer lies in the changing political climate of late eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century Britain. The Company was a trading corporation that had, by this time, become a territorial power ruling large parts of India. Many people in Britain — including members of Parliament, journalists, and reformers — were deeply uneasy about this. They argued that a commercial company should not be allowed to govern millions of people without proper oversight. There were also fierce debates about corruption, the misuse of Indian revenues, and the moral responsibility of Britain towards its Indian subjects. Thinkers like Edmund Burke had earlier led a campaign to impeach Warren Hastings, the first Governor-General of Bengal, on charges of misgovernment. So, by the time the Fifth Report was produced, there was already a strong tradition of parliamentary scrutiny and public debate about the Company’s actions. The report itself became a weapon in the hands of those who wanted to reform or even abolish the Company’s political power.

Important

The debates in England were not just about India. They were also about the nature of British liberty, the dangers of unchecked power, and the question of whether a trading company could ever be a just ruler. The Fifth Report fed directly into these larger political arguments.

Finally, you are asked to analyse any two limitations of this report. This is a crucial skill in historical source analysis — no source is perfect, and the Fifth Report is no exception. …

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.