Q.(i) Which ion amongst the following is colourless and why ? , , (Atomic number of Ti = 22, Cr = 24, V = 23)
You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.
Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →Colour in transition metal ions arises from d–d transitions, which require unpaired d-electrons. has a configuration (no d-electrons), so it cannot undergo d–d transitions and is colourless. is more resistant to oxidation than because its half-filled subshell gives exceptional stability. The highest oxidation state of a metal is achieved with oxygen or fluorine because these are the most electronegative elements, capable of stabilising high positive charges.
(i) Colourless ion:
Why colour appears in transition metal ions
Colour in transition metal ions is primarily due to d–d transitions. When light falls on a transition metal ion, electrons in the lower-energy d-orbitals can absorb energy and jump to higher-energy d-orbitals. The energy gap between these orbitals depends on the metal, its oxidation state, and the surrounding ligands. The absorbed wavelength corresponds to a specific colour; the complementary colour is what we see.
For a d–d transition to occur, the ion must have at least one electron in the d-subshell — that is, the d-orbital must be partially filled. If the d-subshell is completely empty () or completely filled (), no d–d transition is possible, and the ion appears colourless (or white).
Electronic configurations of the given ions
-
: Atomic number of Ti = 22. Ground state: . Removing four electrons (two from 4s and two from 3d) gives : .
→ No d-electrons. No d–d transition. Colourless.
-
: Atomic number of Cr = 24. Ground state: (exception due to half-filled stability). Removing three electrons (one from 4s and two from 3d) gives : .
→ Unpaired d-electrons present. d–d transitions occur. Coloured (typically violet/green).
-
: Atomic number of V = 23. Ground state: . Removing three electrons (two from 4s and one from 3d) gives : .
→ Unpaired d-electrons present. d–d transitions occur. Coloured (typically green).
A common mistake is to think that any transition metal ion is coloured. Remember: and configurations are colourless because no d-electrons are available to jump between d-orbitals. () and () are also colourless for the same reason.
(ii) Why is more resistant to oxidation than
The concept: half-filled subshell stability
A half-filled d-subshell () has all five d-orbitals singly occupied. This arrangement has extra stability due to:
- Exchange energy: Electrons with parallel spins in different orbitals can exchange positions, lowering the total energy. The maximum number of such exchanges occurs in a half-filled set.
- Symmetry: The spherical symmetry of a half-filled subshell distributes electron density evenly, reducing electron–electron repulsion.
Comparing and
| Ion | Electronic configuration | d-electron count | Stability |
|---|---|---|---|
| (half-filled) | Very stable | ||
| Less stable |
- has a half-filled configuration. To oxidise it to , you would have to remove an electron from this stable arrangement, breaking the half-filled stability. This requires a lot of energy, so resists oxidation.
- has a configuration. Oxidising it to gives — a half-filled, more stable configuration. So oxidation is actually favourable for .
Think of it this way: is already at a "peak" of stability (half-filled). Any change makes it less stable. is one electron short of that peak — losing one electron gets it there. So oxidises easily, while does not.
Standard reduction potentials confirm this:
- (high positive value means is hard to oxidise)
- (much lower, so oxidises more readily)
(iii) Highest oxidation state of a metal is shown in its oxide or fluoride only
Why oxygen and fluorine are special
The highest oxidation state of a transition metal represents the maximum number of electrons it can lose (or share) in bonding. To achieve this, the bonding partner must be:
- Highly electronegative — to pull electron density away from the metal.
- Small in size — to form strong, short bonds that stabilise the high charge. …
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.