Q.Show that of all the rectangles inscribed in a given fixed circle, the square has the maximum area.
🔒You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.
🔒 Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →Concept understanding — Optimization Word Problem
Optimization Word Problems
Imagine planning a garden with 40 metres of fencing and wanting the largest rectangular area. A long, thin rectangle wastes space; a square feels roomier; somewhere in between lies the best shape. That is an optimisation problem — a fixed resource and a quantity to make as large (or as small) as possible.
Every optimisation word problem has the same skeleton: the best outcome — maximum area, minimum cost, largest volume, shortest time — under a constraint — limited material, a fixed budget, a given perimeter.
The Plan of Attack
The problem gives you a story, not a graph. Your job is to turn it into a single-variable function and find its peak or valley:
- Name the quantity to optimise — call it Q, and write it using variables.
- Find the constraint — a relation between those variables (e.g. "perimeter =40").
- Reduce to one variable — use the constraint to eliminate the rest.
- Differentiate — solve Q′(x)=0 to find the critical points.
- Confirm — use Q′′(x)<0 for a maximum or Q′′(x)>0 for a minimum.
- Answer the question asked — give the actual dimensions/cost, not just x.
In board exams these problems almost always reduce to a quadratic or cubic. Once Q(x) is written, the calculus is mechanical.
The Garden, Worked
40 m of fencing encloses a rectangle; maximise the area.
- Objective: A=lw.
- Constraint: 2l+2w=40, so l+w=20.
- Reduce: w=20−l, giving A(l)=l(20−l)=20l−l2.
- Differentiate: A′(l)=20−2l=0⟹l=10.
- Confirm: A′′(l)=−2<0, a maximum.
So l=w=10 m — a 10 m × 10 m square.
A common slip: solving A′(l)=0 and stopping. Always check max vs min, and answer in the units asked.
The Common Families
| Problem type | Typical objective | Typical constraint |
|--------------|-------------------|--------------------| …
Take a rectangle inscribed in a circle of radius r; its diagonal is the diameter 2r.
Step 1 — One variable. Let one side be x; the other side is (2r)2−x2=4r2−x2. Area
A=x4r2−x2.
Maximise A2=x2(4r2−x2)=4r2x2−x4 (same maximiser, easier to differentiate).
Step 2 — Differentiate. With f(x)=4r2x2−x4,
f′(x)=8r2x−4x3=4x(2r2−x2)=0⇒x2=2r2⇒x=r2. …
For a rectangle inscribed in a circle of radius r, maximising the area forces both sides equal to r2 — a square — with maximum area 2r2.
The idea
Every rectangle inscribed in a circle has the circle's diameter as its diagonal. That single relation lets us write the area in one variable and maximise it with the derivative (standard CBSE method).
Set up
Let the circle have radius r, so the diameter is 2r. If one side of the rectangle is x, the diagonal condition x2+(other side)2=(2r)2 gives the other side 4r2−x2. The area is
A(x)=x4r2−x2,0<x<2r.
Work the steps
- Work with A2 to avoid the square root. Since A>0, maximising A is the same as maximising
f(x)=A2=x2(4r2−x2)=4r2x2−x4.
- Differentiate:
f′(x)=8r2x−4x3=4x(2r2−x2).
- Solve f′(x)=0: since x>0, we need 2r2−x2=0, i.e. x2=2r2, so x=r2.
- Second-derivative test: …
Method: Optimization Proofs Using the "Maximize A2" Trick (Inscribed-Figure Problems)
This method proves a geometric optimization claim (e.g. "the square has maximum area among inscribed rectangles") by expressing the objective in terms of a single geometric parameter and avoiding messy square-root differentiation.
Steps
Step 1: Use the geometric constraint to relate the two dimensions
For a rectangle inscribed in a circle of radius r, the diagonal of the rectangle equals the circle's diameter, 2r. If one side is x, the other side is determined by the Pythagorean relation:
other side=(2r)2−x2
Step 2: Write the objective (area) as a function of the single variable
A(x)=x4r2−x2
Step 3: Maximize A2 instead of A directly
Since A(x)>0 on the valid domain, maximizing A(x) is equivalent to maximizing A(x)2 — and squaring removes the square root, turning the problem into a polynomial that's much easier to differentiate:
f(x)=A(x)2=x2(4r2−x2) …
Common Mistakes
Mistake 1: Differentiating the square-root expression x4r2−x2 directly
Why it's wrong: this requires the chain rule on a square root, which is more error-prone (a common slip is mishandling the 2⋅1 factor) than the equivalent, cleaner polynomial approach. Correct approach: square the objective first, since A>0 means maximizing A2 gives the same maximizing x, and differentiate the resulting polynomial instead.
Mistake 2: Stopping after finding x=r2 without confirming the shape is a square
Why it's wrong: the question specifically asks to show the maximizing rectangle is a square — finding the optimal x alone doesn't demonstrate that; a student must also substitute back to find the other side and explicitly verify it equals x. Correct approach: always complete the geometric conclusion the problem asks for, not just the calculus. …
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markQ.(Continuing the aluminium-box case study of Q.38) What will be the dimensions of the largest box?
›Reveal solutionSolution
Substitute the optimal square side x=32 m (found by maximising the volume function) into the length, breadth and height expressions.
From the case study, cutting a square of side x from each corner of the 3 m×8 m sheet and folding up the sides gives a box of:
- Length =(8−2x) m
- Breadth =(3−2x) m
- Height =x m
Maximising V(x)=x(3−2x)(8−2x)=4x3−22x2+24x using V′(x)=12x2−44x+24=0 (i.e. 3x2−11x+6=0) gives roots x=3 or x=32. Since 0<x<1.5 is required for the box to be valid, the admissible root is x=32, and V′′(32)=−28<0 confirms this is the maximum.
Substituting x=32:
Length=8−2(32)=8−34=320 m …
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markQ.(Continuing the aluminium-box case study of Q.38) What will be the side of the square removed to form the largest box?
›Reveal solutionSolution
The optimal square side is the critical point of the volume function that lies in the valid domain and satisfies the second-derivative maximum test.
For a square of side x removed from each corner of the 3 m×8 m sheet, the box volume is:
V(x)=x(3−2x)(8−2x)=4x3−22x2+24x,0<x<1.5
Differentiating and setting V′(x)=0:
V′(x)=12x2−44x+24=0⟹3x2−11x+6=0
x=611±121−72=611±7⟹x=3 or x=32
Since the breadth (3−2x) must stay positive, only x<1.5 is valid, so x=3 is rejected and x=32 is the only admissible critical point.
Confirming it is a maximum: …
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markQ.A gardener plans to plant flowers in a rectangular flower bed in such a way that a rectangle is inscribed in the semi-circular field (as shown in the figure). Radius of the semi-circular field is 30 m. Let the length of the rectangle be PQ = x m. Based on above information answer the following: What will be the breadth of the rectangular flower bed in terms of x?
›Reveal solutionSolution
The rectangle's top corners lie on the semicircle of radius 30, so the Pythagorean relation between half the length and the breadth gives the breadth as a function of x.
Place the centre O of the semicircle at the origin, with the diameter along the x-axis. Since the rectangle PQRS is symmetric about O with top side PQ=x, the top corners P,Q are at horizontal distance x/2 from O. Let the breadth (height of the rectangle) be b. …
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markQ.A gardener plans to plant flowers in a rectangular flower bed in such a way that a rectangle is inscribed in the semi-circular field (as shown in the figure). Radius of the semi-circular field is 30 m. Let the length of the rectangle be PQ = x m. Based on above information answer the following: What will be the area of rectangular region as a function of x?
›Reveal solutionSolution
Area = length × breadth, using the breadth found in terms of x.
The rectangle has length PQ=x and breadth b=900−x2/4 (from the semicircle constraint). So the area is …
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markQ.A gardener plans to plant flowers in a rectangular flower bed in such a way that a rectangle is inscribed in the semi-circular field (as shown in the figure). Radius of the semi-circular field is 30 m. Let the length of the rectangle be PQ = x m. Based on above information answer the following: Gardener wants maximum area for the rectangular flower bed. For this to happen, what will be the value of x?
›Reveal solutionSolution
Maximize A(x)2 (equivalent and algebraically simpler) by setting its derivative to zero.
From A(x)=x900−x2/4, consider A2=x2(900−4x2)=900x2−4x4 (maximizing A2 maximizes A since A≥0).
dxd(A2)=1800x−x3=x(1800−x2)
Setting this to zero: x=0 (rejected, gives zero area) or x2=1800⇒x=1800=302.
…
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markQ.A gardener plans to plant flowers in a rectangular flower bed in such a way that a rectangle is inscribed in the semi-circular field (as shown in the figure). Radius of the semi-circular field is 30 m. Let the length of the rectangle be PQ = x m. Based on above information answer the following: What will be the area of remaining field (in sq. m) after having the flower bed of maximum area?
›Reveal solutionSolution
Subtract the maximum rectangle area from the total semicircular field area.
Total area of the semicircular field: 21πr2=21π(30)2=450π sq. m.
At maximum, x=302, so breadth b=900−4(302)2=900−41800=900−450=450=152.
…
- CBSE 2024Set ANNUAL1 markQ.[Case study] Let a cone be inscribed in a sphere of radius R. The height and radius of the cone are h and r respectively; x denotes the distance from the sphere's centre O to the centre of the cone's base. Write the relation between r and R in terms of x.
›Reveal solutionSolution
r2=R2−x2.
From the figure, O is the sphere's centre, C is the centre of the cone's circular base, OC=x, CA=r (radius of the cone's base), and OA=R (a radius of the sphere, since A lies on the sphere).
…
- CBSE 2024Set ANNUAL1 markQ.[Case study, same setup as above — cone of height h, radius r inscribed in a sphere of radius R, with x the distance from the sphere's centre to the cone's base] Write the volume V of the cone in terms of R and x.
›Reveal solutionSolution
V=3π(R+x)2(R−x).
From the figure, the cone's height is h=R+x (from the base at C up to the apex D at the top of the sphere), and from the previous part, r2=R2−x2.
Volume of a cone: V=31πr2h. …
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.