Q.What are the differences between Coulomb force and gravitational force?
Concept understanding — Inverse Square Law Comparison
The Intuition: Why Does Light Get Dimmer So Fast?
Imagine you're standing near a campfire. You feel its warmth on your face. Now take ten steps back. Does the warmth feel half as strong? No — it feels much weaker, maybe a quarter as strong. That's not an accident. It's a pattern that shows up everywhere in physics: gravity, light, sound, electric fields, even radiation.
The reason is simple: as you move away from a source, the same amount of energy (or force) has to spread out over a larger area. And that area grows with the square of the distance.
The Core Idea in One Picture
Think of a light bulb at the centre of a balloon. As you inflate the balloon, the light hitting the inner surface spreads thinner and thinner. If you double the radius of the balloon, the surface area becomes four times larger. So each patch of the balloon gets only one-fourth the light.
That's the inverse square law in a nutshell: double the distance → one-fourth the intensity.
The Precise Statement
I∝r21orI=r2k
where:
- I = intensity (brightness, force per unit area, etc.)
- r = distance from the source
- k = a constant that depends on the source's strength
If you compare two distances r1 and r2, the ratio of intensities is:
I1I2=(r2r1)2
This is the inverse square law comparison — you compare how strong a quantity is at two different distances by taking the inverse ratio of the squares of those distances.
Why "Inverse Square" and Not Just "Inverse"?
Because the geometry of space is three-dimensional. The surface of a sphere is 4πr2. As r grows, the sphere's surface grows as r2. Whatever is radiating outward (light, sound, gravity) must pass through that entire surface. So the amount per unit area drops as 1/r2.
If we lived in a flat, two-dimensional world, the law would be 1/r (like ripples on a pond). In one dimension, it would be constant. The inverse square law is a direct consequence of living in three dimensions.
The Comparison: What It Really Means
When you compare two situations, you're not calculating absolute intensity — you're finding the ratio. For example:
A star is 3 times farther away than another identical star. How much dimmer does it appear?
InearIfar=(31)2=91
The farther star is 9 times dimmer. Not 3 times — 9 times. That's the punch of the square.
A common mistake: thinking "twice the distance means half the intensity." It's actually one-fourth. The square makes the drop much steeper than linear intuition suggests.
Where This Law Applies (and Where It Doesn't)
Applies to:
- Light from a point source (a star, a bulb)
- Sound from a small source (a speaker in open air)
- Gravitational force between two masses
- Electric force between two charges
- Radiation from a radioactive point source
Does NOT apply to:
- Light from a laser beam (it stays collimated)
- Sound inside a pipe (it's guided)
- Gravity inside a planet (the mass distribution changes the law)
- Very large distances in cosmology (space itself is expanding)
The One-Line Takeaway
Inverse square law comparison: When distance multiplies by n, intensity divides by n2. Always compare using the square of the distance ratio, not the distance itself.
That's the whole idea. The rest is just practice applying it to different problems — but the geometry never changes.
Searches such as "inverse square law examples physics" and "intensity distance relationship formula" recur across gravitation, electrostatics, and optics topics in the NCERT/CBSE Class 11-12 Physics curriculum, since this same 1/r2 pattern underlies all of them. Comparing intensities at two distances is a very common numerical-question format in JEE Main and NEET.
Why this formula?
Inverse Square Law Comparison — Why the Formula Holds
The Inverse Square Law appears in physics wherever a quantity spreads out uniformly from a point source in three-dimensional space. The core idea is that the intensity (or field strength) decreases as the square of the distance from the source.
1. The Intuition: Spreading Over a Sphere
Imagine a point source emitting energy, light, sound, or gravitational force equally in all directions.
- At a distance r, the energy is spread uniformly over the surface area of a sphere of radius r.
- The surface area of a sphere is:
A=4πr2
If the total power (or flux) emitted by the source is P, then the intensity I (power per unit area) at distance r is:
I=4πr2P
Key insight: The same total power is spread over a larger and larger area as r increases. Hence, intensity is inversely proportional to r2.
2. Derivation for Gravitational Force (Newton's Law)
Newton’s law of gravitation states:
F=r2GMm
Why 1/r2?
- The gravitational field lines from a point mass M radiate outward uniformly.
- The number of field lines crossing a sphere of radius r is constant (conservation of flux).
- The density of field lines (force per unit mass) at distance r is:
g=r2GM
- This is because the total flux Φ=4πGM is spread over 4πr2, giving:
g=4πr2Φ=r2GM
Thus, the force on a test mass m is F=mg=r2GMm.
3. Derivation for Coulomb's Law (Electrostatics)
Coulomb’s law for electric force between two point charges q1 and q2:
F=r2kq1q2
Why 1/r2?
- Electric field lines from a point charge q radiate radially outward (or inward for negative charge).
- Gauss’s law states that the total electric flux through a closed surface is proportional to the enclosed charge:
∮E⋅dA=ε0q
- For a sphere of radius r centered on the charge, the field is radial and constant in magnitude:
E⋅4πr2=ε0q
- Therefore:
E=4πε01r2q
- The force on a test charge q2 is F=q2E=4πε01r2q1q2.
4. Derivation for Light/Radiation Intensity
For a point source of light emitting power P:
- At distance r, the power is spread over a sphere of area 4πr2.
- Illuminance (intensity) is:
I=4πr2P
Why not 1/r?
- In 2D (e.g., a line source), intensity falls as 1/r because the circumference of a circle is 2πr.
- In 3D, the surface area grows as r2, so intensity falls as 1/r2.
5. The Common Mathematical Reason
All inverse square laws arise from conservation of flux in three-dimensional space with isotropic emission. The geometry forces:
Intensity∝r21
because the area over which the quantity spreads is proportional to r2.
6. Key Exam Points
| Quantity | Formula | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Gravitational force | F=r2GMm | Flux of field lines over sphere area |
| Electric force | F=r2kq1q2 | Gauss’s law + spherical symmetry |
| Light intensity | I=4πr2P | Power spread over sphere surface |
| Sound intensity | I=4πr2P | Same geometric spreading |
Important: The inverse square law holds only for point sources in 3D space with no absorption or reflection. For extended sources or non-isotropic emission, the law is modified.
7. Common Misconception
- Not because "the force gets weaker with distance" — that’s vague.
- The exact 1/r2 comes from the geometry of a sphere, not from any arbitrary assumption.
- If space had 2 dimensions, the law would be 1/r; if 4 dimensions, 1/r3.
Final takeaway: The inverse square law is a geometric necessity for any conserved quantity spreading uniformly from a point in three-dimensional space. Memorize the formula, but understand the sphere-area argument — it’s the core reasoning for every exam question.
Coulomb force can repel or attract and depends on the medium; gravity is always attractive and medium-independent.
They differ in sign (attract/repel vs always attract), relative strength (k >> G), and medium dependence.
Step 1. Gravitational force is always attractive; Coulomb force can be attractive (unlike charges) or repulsive (like charges).
Step 2. The constant k=9×109 N m2C−2 in Coulomb's law is vastly larger than G=6.67×10−11 N m2kg−2, so for charged particles such as a proton and electron, the electrostatic force dominates the gravitational force by a factor of about 1039.
Step 3. Gravitational force is independent of the surrounding medium, but the Coulomb force weakens in a medium of relative permittivity εr>1 (e.g. reduced 80-fold in water). Both, however, are inverse-square-law, conservative, central forces.
They differ in sign (attract/repel vs always attract), relative strength (k≫G), and medium dependence (Coulomb force weakens in a medium, gravity does not).
List the three contrasts: sign of the force, relative magnitude of the constants, and dependence on the surrounding medium.
- Forgetting that both forces do share the same inverse-square distance dependence -- the differences are in sign, strength and medium, not in the power of r.
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.The electric field E at a distance r due to a point charge is:(a) E ∝ r(b) E ∝ 1/r²(c) E ∝ 1/r(d) E ∝ 1/r³
›Reveal solutionSolution
By Coulomb's law the field of a point charge is E=4πε01r2q, so E∝1/r2.
The force on a small test charge q0 placed at distance r from a point charge q is F=4πε01r2qq0 (Coulomb's law). The electric field is defined as force per unit test charge, E=F/q0=4πε01r2q. Since q and the constant 4πε01 do not depend on r, the field varies only through the 1/r2 term. This is why field lines from a point charge spread out over a larger area as r grows and the field strength weakens rapidly with distance — doubling the distance cuts the field to a quarter.
✓Final answer(b) E ∝ 1/r²
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.The force between two point charges placed at distance r apart, is F. If the distance increased to 2r between the charges then force will be(a) F(b) F/2(c) F/4(d) F/8
›Reveal solutionSolution
Coulomb's force follows an inverse-square law, so doubling the separation cuts the force to one-quarter.
Coulomb's law: F=4πε01r2q1q2=r2kq1q2
At separation r: F=r2kq1q2
At separation 2r: F′=(2r)2kq1q2=4r2kq1q2=4F
✓Final answer(c) F/4.
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.When the distance between the charges is halved, the force between the charges become :(a) half(b) twice(c) four times(d) none of these
›Reveal solutionSolution
By Coulomb's law F∝1/r2; halving the separation r quadruples the force.
Coulomb's law states
F=4πε01r2q1q2
If the distance is halved, r′=r/2, then
F′=(r/2)2kq1q2=r2/4kq1q2=4×r2kq1q2=4F
So the force becomes four times the original value.
✓Final answerThe force becomes four times — option (c).
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markQ.Two charged metallic spheres with radii R1 and R2 respectively are brought in contact and then separated they carry same charge after separation. What is the ratio of electric fields at the surface of two sphere after separation?
›Reveal solutionSolution
Surface field E=kQ/R2; with equal charge Q on each sphere, E∝1/R2.
The electric field at the surface of a charged conducting sphere of radius R carrying charge Q is E=R2kQ. Given that after separation both spheres carry the same charge Q (as stated), the field at each surface is inversely proportional to the square of its own radius:
E2E1=Q/R22Q/R12=R12R22
✓Final answerE1:E2=R22:R12.
- CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.If both the charges and distance between them is doubled, then the new electrostatic force will be(a) F(b) 2F(c) 3F(d) 4F
›Reveal solutionSolution
Doubling both charges and the distance leaves the electrostatic force unchanged because the charge-product factor of 4 exactly cancels the distance-squared factor of 4.
Coulomb's law: F=4πε01r2q1q2=kr2q1q2
Let the new charges be q1′=2q1, q2′=2q2, and the new separation r′=2r.
F′=kr′2q1′q2′=k(2r)2(2q1)(2q2)=k4r24q1q2=kr2q1q2=F
So the new force F′=F, exactly the same as before.
✓Final answerThe correct option is (a) F — the force remains unchanged.
- CBSE 2023Set MODEL1 markMCQQ.An electric charge q is placed in vacuum. The electric field intensity E at a point P at r-distance from charge will be:(a) E∝r1(b) E∝r21(c) E∝r(d) E∝r31
›Reveal solutionSolution
The electric field of a point charge falls off as the inverse square of distance.
By Coulomb's law, the electric field due to a point charge q at a distance r is
E=4πε01r2q
so for a fixed charge q, E∝r21.
✓Final answer(b) E∝r21
- CBSE 2023Set F1 markMCQQ.The ratio of electric force and gravitational force acting between two charges is in the order of (A) 10^42 (B) 10^39 (C) 10^36 (D) 1
›Reveal solutionSolution
For two electrons, Fe/Fg≈4×1042 — order 10⁴².
Both forces between two identical charges (electrons) obey an inverse-square law, so the distance cancels in the ratio:
FgFe=Gr2me24πε01r2e2=4πε0Gme2e2.
Putting e=1.6×10−19 C and me=9.1×10−31 kg gives ≈4×1042 — i.e. of order 1042.
(For an electron–proton pair the value is ~2.4×1039, and for two protons ~1036; for two like charges of electronic mass the standard textbook figure is 1042.)
✓Final answer(A) 10⁴².
- CBSE 2023Set ANNUAL1 markQ.Between an electron and a proton, which is stronger, the electrostatic force or the gravitational force?
›Reveal solutionSolution
Coulomb's law force between an electron and proton vastly exceeds Newton's gravitational force between them, because e²/(4πε₀) is enormously larger than Gm_em_p.
Electrostatic force: Fe=4πε01r2e2. Gravitational force: Fg=r2Gmemp.
Taking the ratio (the r2 cancels): FgFe=Gmempe2/4πε0≈2.3×1039
So the electrostatic force is about 1039 times stronger than gravity at the same separation — gravity is utterly negligible at the atomic scale.
✓Final answerThe electrostatic (Coulomb) force is far stronger — roughly 1039 times the gravitational force.
- CBSE 2022Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Two charges +1μC and +8μC are situated at a distance in air. The ratio of forces acting on them is:(a) 1 : 8(b) 8 : 1(c) 1 : 1(d) 1 : 16
›Reveal solutionSolution
The forces are an action–reaction pair, so they are equal in magnitude: ratio 1 : 1, option (C).
The Coulomb force each charge exerts on the other is
F=4πϵ01r2q1q2.
Both charges share the same product q1q2 and the same separation r, so the magnitude is identical for each. This is also required by Newton's third law: the force on charge 1 due to charge 2 is equal and opposite to the force on charge 2 due to charge 1.
Hence the ratio of forces is 1:1, independent of the fact that the charges are 1μC and 8μC.
✓Final answer(C) 1 : 1.
- CBSE 2020Set ANNUAL1 markQ.The force of attraction between a positively charged particle and a negatively charged particle is F. When distance between them is made one fourth, what will be the value of this force?
›Reveal solutionSolution
By Coulomb's law F∝1/r2; reducing distance to one-fourth increases force 16 times.
Coulomb's law: F=4πε01r2q1q2, so F∝r21.
If new distance r′=r/4:
F′=4πε01(r/4)2q1q2=16×4πε01r2q1q2=16F
✓Final answerThe new force is 16F (16 times the original force).
- CBSE 2018Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.When the distance between two charged particles is doubled, the force between them becomes: (A) one-fourth (B) half (C) double (D) four times
›Reveal solutionSolution
By Coulomb's law, force varies as 1/r2, so doubling r divides the force by 4.
Coulomb's law gives the force between two point charges q1,q2 separated by distance r as
F=4πε01r2q1q2
If the separation is doubled, r→2r, then
F′=4πε01(2r)2q1q2=41(4πε01r2q1q2)=4F
So the force reduces to one-fourth.
✓Final answerThe force becomes one-fourth — option (A).
- CBSE 2018Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.The intensity of electric field E due to charge Q at distance r :(a) E ∝ r(b) E ∝ 1/r(c) E ∝ 1/r²(d) E ∝ 1/r³
›Reveal solutionSolution
By Coulomb's law the field of a point charge is E = kQ/r², so E ∝ 1/r².
The electric field intensity at a point is the force per unit positive test charge. For a point charge Q, the magnitude of the field at distance r is
E = (1/4πε₀) × (Q / r²) = kQ/r²,
where k = 1/4πε₀ = 9 × 10⁹ N·m²/C². The distance r appears squared in the denominator, so as r increases the field decreases as the inverse square of r.
Comparing with the options: E is not proportional to r, nor to 1/r, nor to 1/r³ — it is proportional to 1/r².
✓Final answer(c) E ∝ 1/r².
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.