Skip to content
NCERT Exemplar · Q3

Q.The increasing order of reduction of alkyl halides with zinc and dilute HCl is

(i) R-Cl < R-I < R-Br
(ii) R-Cl < R-Br < R-I
(iii) R-I < R-Br < R-Cl
(iv) R-Br < R-I < R-Cl
Yanam CbseMCQ· 1mImportance★★★★★
47% · 42/90 Questions
✓ Free question

The reduction of alkyl halides by Zn/dil. HCl follows the ease of C–X bond cleavage: weaker bonds react faster. Since bond strength decreases I > Br > Cl, the increasing order of reduction (slowest to fastest) is R–I < R–Br < R–Cl.

Why bond strength governs reduction rate

When zinc and dilute HCl reduce an alkyl halide to an alkane, the first and rate-determining step is breaking the carbon–halogen bond. Zinc donates electrons (acts as a reducing agent), and the halogen must leave as a halide ion:

R−X+Zn+HCl→R−H+ZnClX2+HX\ce{R-X + Zn + HCl -> R-H + ZnCl_2 + HX}

The ease of reduction depends on how readily the C–X bond breaks. A weaker bond snaps more easily, so the reaction proceeds faster. Conversely, a stronger bond resists cleavage, making reduction slower.

The C–X bond strengths follow the order:

C–I<C–Br<C–Cl\text{C–I} < \text{C–Br} < \text{C–Cl}

Iodine is the largest halogen; its valence electrons are far from the nucleus and poorly overlap with carbon's orbital, yielding a weak bond. Chlorine is smallest, with tight overlap and a strong bond. Bromine sits in between.

Important

Weaker bond = faster reduction. The halide that holds on most weakly (R–I) reacts fastest; the one that grips tightest (R–Cl) reacts slowest.

Resolving the question's wording

The question asks for the increasing order of reduction. In chemistry, "increasing order" of a rate or reactivity means arranging from slowest to fastest (least reactive to most reactive).

Because R–I has the weakest bond, it reduces most readily (fastest). R–Cl, with the strongest bond, reduces least readily (slowest). Therefore:

Increasing order of reduction (slowest → fastest):

R–Cl<R–Br<R–I\text{R–Cl} < \text{R–Br} < \text{R–I}

Reading left to right: R–Cl is the slowest (least reduced), R–I is the fastest (most reduced).

Watch out

Do not confuse "increasing order of reduction" with "increasing bond strength." The two run in opposite directions. Stronger bonds reduce more slowly.

Matching the options

  1. (i) R–Cl < R–I < R–Br: incorrect order; places R–I in the middle.
  2. (ii) R–Cl < R–Br < R–I: matches our reasoning—slowest to fastest.
  3. (iii) R–I < R–Br < R–Cl: inverted; this would be decreasing order of reduction (fastest to slowest).
  4. (iv) R–Br < R–I < R–Cl: incorrect order.
✓Final answer

The correct option is (ii): R–Cl < R–Br < R–I.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.