Skip to content
Question

Q.During the 1850s in the pre-industrialisation era in England, the expected effect of natural selection on the number of dark-winged moths as compared to white-winged moths was : (A) more in number (B) less in number (C) both were equal in number (D) both were less in number

CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2024MCQ· 1mImportance★★★★★
✓ Free question

Before industrialisation, tree bark was light-coloured and lichen-covered, making dark-winged moths conspicuous to predators while white-winged moths were camouflaged. Natural selection favoured the white form, so dark-winged moths were less in number.

This question tests your understanding of industrial melanism in Biston betularia (the peppered moth), one of the most elegant real-world demonstrations of natural selection in action. The key is to think about the environment before the soot and pollution arrived.

Natural selection operates through differential survival: individuals whose traits make them better camouflaged against predators leave more offspring. The trait frequencies in a population shift toward whatever the environment favours at that moment.

In pre-industrial England during the 1850s, the countryside was unpolluted. Tree trunks and branches were covered with light-coloured lichens, creating a pale, mottled background. Now picture two moths resting on such a tree:

  1. The white-winged (light) moth blends beautifully into the lichen-covered bark. Birds hunting by sight struggle to spot it.

  2. The dark-winged (melanic) moth stands out starkly against the pale background—a conspicuous target for any insectivorous bird.

Predation pressure acts as the selective force. Birds preferentially eat the moths they can see most easily. The dark moths suffer higher predation rates, so fewer survive to reproduce. Over generations, the dark allele remains rare in the population because its carriers are removed before they can pass it on.

Tip

Remember the rule: camouflage = survival. Whichever morph matches the background at the time will be favoured by selection.

The situation reversed dramatically during industrialisation (post-1850s). Soot blackened the trees and killed the lichens, turning the environment dark. Suddenly the dark-winged moths had the camouflage advantage, and their frequency soared—a shift documented by collectors and later confirmed experimentally. But in the 1850s, before that environmental change, the light background meant light moths dominated.

Watch out

Don't confuse the timeline. The question specifies the 1850s pre-industrialisation era—this is before the famous increase in melanic forms. The dark moths were still rare at this point.

✓Final answer

The correct option is (B): dark-winged moths were less in number than white-winged moths during the pre-industrialisation era.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.