Q.Check whether the relation R in the set N of natural numbers given by R={(a,b):a is divisor of b} is reflexive, symmetric or transitive. Also determine whether R is an equivalence relation.
🔒You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.
🔒 Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →Part (a)Concept understanding — Reflexive Transitive Not Symmetric
Reflexive, Transitive, Not Symmetric — A First Look
What kind of relation is reflexive and transitive but not symmetric? "Same grade as" won't do — it's symmetric. We need a relation that only goes one way. Let's build it.
The Intuition: A One-Way Street
The classic example is "divides" on the positive integers:
- Reflexive: every number divides itself. 5∣5. ✓
- Transitive: if a∣b and b∣c, then a∣c. E.g. 2∣4 and 4∣12 gives 2∣12. ✓
- Not symmetric: 2∣4 is true, but 4∣2 is false. The relation goes only one way. ✓
The key insight: the relation can go from smaller to larger (or equal), but not back.
The Precise Statement
Let R be a relation on a set S. Then:
Reflexive: ∀a∈S,aRa
Transitive: ∀a,b,c∈S,(aRb∧bRc)⟹aRc
Not symmetric: ∃a,b∈S such that aRb but bRa
"Reflexive transitive not symmetric" is just a checklist of three properties — not a standard name like "equivalence relation". A relation with these (plus antisymmetry) is a partial order.
Why This Matters
Exams often ask: "Is this relation reflexive? Symmetric? Transitive?" Test each property independently — a relation can be reflexive and transitive but fail symmetry, and that's perfectly fine. For example, on the reals define xRy if x≤y: reflexive yes, transitive yes, symmetric no (3≤5 but 5≤3).
A common mistake: assuming that reflexive + transitive forces symmetry. False — both "divides" and "≤" disprove it. Always test each property separately.
A Quick Table for Clarity
| Property | Meaning | Example: "divides" on N |
|---|---|---|
| Reflexive | Every element relates to itself | 3∣3 ✓ |
Part (b)Concept understanding — Inverse Tangent Identity
Inverse Tangent Identities
The inverse tangent function obeys a family of addition and doubling identities that let you combine two arctangents into one. They come straight from the tangent addition formula, but they carry conditions you must respect.
The core addition identity
Start from tan(A+B)=1−tanAtanBtanA+tanB. Put A=tan−1x and B=tan−1y, so tanA=x and tanB=y. Then
tan−1x+tan−1y=tan−1(1−xyx+y),xy<1.
The restriction xy<1 keeps the combined angle inside the principal range (−π/2,π/2).
If xy>1 the raw formula lands in the wrong branch, so you must correct it:
tan−1x+tan−1y=π+tan−1(1−xyx+y) (x,y>0),
and −π+tan−1(⋅) when x,y<0. Ignoring this is the classic exam slip.
Subtraction
Replacing y with −y gives
tan−1x−tan−1y=tan−1(1+xyx−y),xy>−1.
The doubling identity
Set y=x in the addition formula:
2tan−1x=tan−1(1−x22x),−1<x<1.
The same angle can also be rewritten through sine and cosine, which is handy in integration and in proofs -- but each alternate form only matches 2tan−1x on part of its domain, so the two forms carry different conditions:
2tan−1x=sin−1(1+x22x),−1≤x≤1,
2tan−1x=cos−1(1+x21−x2),x≥0.
The cos−1 form needs x≥0 -- it fails for negative x. Check x=−1: 2tan−1(−1)=2(−4π)=−2π, but cos−1(1+11−1)=cos−1(0)=2π, the wrong sign entirely. The sin−1 form has no such restriction because sin−1 (unlike cos−1) can return a negative angle.
The complementary identity
For every real x,
tan−1x+cot−1x=2π.
This holds without restriction because tan−1 and cot−1 of the same value are complementary angles. …
Part (a)
R={(a,b):a is a divisor of b} on N.
- Reflexive: a∣a for all a, so (a,a)∈R. ✓
- Symmetric: 2∣4 but 4∤2, so (2,4)∈R while (4,2)∈/R. ✗ …
- The divisibility relation on N is reflexive and transitive but not symmetric ⇒ not an equivalence relation.
- Both sides reduce to tan−121, so the identity holds.
Part (a)
R={(a,b):a divides b} on N.
Reflexive. a=1⋅a, so a∣a and (a,a)∈R for every a. ✓
Symmetric. Counterexample a=2, b=4: 2∣4 so (2,4)∈R, but 4∤2 so (4,2)∈/R. Not symmetric. ✗
Transitive. If a∣b and b∣c, then b=ak and c=bm for some k,m∈N. Substituting, c=(ak)m=a(km), so a∣c and (a,c)∈R. ✓ …
Showing the 12 most recent of 44 on this concept.
- CBSE 2026Set 65/2/11 markMCQQ.A relation R on set A={1,2,3} defined as R={(1,1),(2,2),(1,2)} is (A) Reflexive only (B) Reflexive and Transitive (C) Symmetric and Transitive (D) Transitive only
›Reveal solutionSolution
On A={1,2,3}, R is not reflexive (missing (3,3)), not symmetric (has (1,2) but not (2,1)), and is transitive. So R is transitive only — option (D).
Check each property of R={(1,1),(2,2),(1,2)} on A={1,2,3}.
Reflexive? Requires (a,a)∈R for every a∈A, i.e. (1,1),(2,2),(3,3). Since 3∈A but (3,3)∈/R, R is not reflexive.
Symmetric? Requires (b,a)∈R whenever (a,b)∈R. Here (1,2)∈R but (2,1)∈/R, so R is not symmetric.
Transitive? Requires (a,c)∈R whenever (a,b),(b,c)∈R. The only linking pairs are: …
- CBSE 2026Set A1 markMCQQ.tan−1(−31)=(a) 3π(b) 6π(c) −3π(d) −6π
›Reveal solutionSolution
tan−1(−31)=−6π.
The principal value of tan−1 lies in (−2π,2π).
We need the angle θ in this range with tanθ=−31.
…
- CBSE 2026Set A1 markMCQQ.2tan−131=(a) tan−123(b) tan−143(c) tan−134(d) tan−132
›Reveal solutionSolution
2tan−131=tan−143.
Use the double-angle identity valid for ∣x∣<1:
2tan−1x=tan−11−x22x.
Here x=31: …
- CBSE 2026Set A1 markMCQQ.x∈R, cot(tan−1x+cot−1x)=(a) 1(b) 21(c) 0(d) 31
›Reveal solutionSolution
cot(tan−1x+cot−1x)=cot2π=0.
For all real x, the complementary identity gives
tan−1x+cot−1x=2π.
Therefore …
- CBSE 2026Set A1 markMCQQ.tan−12+tan−13=(a) −4π(b) 4π(c) 43π(d) π
›Reveal solutionSolution
tan−12+tan−13=43π.
Use the addition formula. With a=2, b=3 we have ab=6>1, so
tan−1a+tan−1b=π+tan−11−aba+b.
Compute:
1−aba+b=1−65=−55=−1.
So …
- CBSE 2026Set A1 markMCQQ.tan−1yx−tan−1x+yx−y=(a) −43π(b) 2π(c) 4π(d) 3π
›Reveal solutionSolution
tan−1yx−tan−1x+yx−y=4π.
Use tan−1a−tan−1b=tan−11+aba−b with a=yx, b=x+yx−y.
Numerator:
a−b=yx−x+yx−y=y(x+y)x(x+y)−y(x−y)=y(x+y)x2+xy−xy+y2=y(x+y)x2+y2.
Denominator: …
- CBSE 2026Set A1 markMCQQ.∣x∣≤1, cos−1(1+x21−x2)=(a) 2cos−1x(b) 2sin−1x(c) 2tan−1x(d) tan−12x
›Reveal solutionSolution
cos−11+x21−x2=2tan−1x (for 0≤x≤1).
Put x=tanθ, so θ=tan−1x. Then
1+x21−x2=1+tan2θ1−tan2θ=cos2θ.
Therefore …
- CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.Let R = {(4, 4), (6, 6), (7, 7), (4, 6), (6, 4), (4, 7), (6, 7)} be a relation defined on A = {4, 6, 7}, then this relation R is ................. .(a) Reflexive, not symmetric and not transitive(b) Reflexive, symmetric and transitive(c) Reflexive and transitive but not symmetric(d) Neither Reflexive, nor symmetric and nor transitive
›Reveal solutionSolution
Check reflexivity, symmetry and transitivity directly against the listed ordered pairs.
Reflexive: (4,4),(6,6),(7,7) are all present in R, so R is reflexive.
Symmetric: (4,6)∈R and (6,4)∈R is fine, but (4,7)∈R while (7,4)∈/R. So R is NOT symmetric.
…
- CBSE 2025Set E1 markMCQQ.cot−1(tan7π)=(a) 7π(b) 145π(c) 149π(d) 143π
›Reveal solutionSolution
Convert the tangent to a cotangent using complementary angles; the answer is 145π.
Use tanθ=cot(2π−θ):
tan7π=cot(2π−7π)=cot147π−2π=cot145π.
…
- CBSE 2025Set E1 markMCQQ.tan−1(−3)=(a) 6π(b) 3π(c) 32π(d) −3π
›Reveal solutionSolution
tan−1 is an odd function with principal range (−2π,2π); the value is −3π.
Since tan3π=3 and tan−1(−x)=−tan−1x, …
- CBSE 2025Set E1 markMCQQ.tan−1(3)−cot−1(−3)=(a) 0(b) −2π(c) π(d) 2π
›Reveal solutionSolution
Evaluate each inverse function in its principal range and subtract; result −2π.
First, tan−1(3)=3π.
For cot−1(−3), the principal range of cot−1 is (0,π). We need cotθ=−3 with θ∈(0,π). Since cot6π=3,
cot−1(−3)=π−6π=65π.
…
- CBSE 2025Set E1 markMCQQ.tan−121+tan−131=(a) π(b) 4π(c) 2π(d) 3π
›Reveal solutionSolution
Use the sum formula for inverse tangents; the sum is 4π.
When xy<1, tan−1x+tan−1y=tan−11−xyx+y. Here xy=61<1, so …
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.