How would a social learning theorist account for a phobic fear of lizards/cockroaches? How would a psychoanalyst account for the same phobia?

Question

Accepted Answer

> [!TLDR]
> A social learning theorist explains a lizard/cockroach phobia as faulty learning — acquired by conditioning, avoidance-based negative reinforcement, or observing others' fear; a psychoanalyst explains the same phobia as an expression of unresolved intrapsychic conflicts and childhood fears buried in the unconscious.

**The social learning (behaviour) theorist's account**

Behaviour therapies postulate that psychological problems arise due to **faulty learning of behaviours and cognitions**; faulty conditioning patterns lead to maladaptive behaviours. A social learning theorist would therefore explain the phobic fear of lizards or cockroaches as a *learned* response:

- **Faulty (classical) conditioning.** The lizard/cockroach may have become associated with a frightening or anxiety-provoking experience, so that the previously neutral creature now evokes fear — an acquired, conditioned response.
- **Negative reinforcement / maintenance.** Responses that let one *avoid or escape* the feared object (running away, avoiding places where they appear) reduce anxiety; this relief acts as **negative reinforcement**, strengthening and maintaining the avoidance and hence the phobia.
- **Vicarious learning / modelling.** Learning by *observing others* — for example, seeing a parent or another role model react with fear or disgust towards lizards/cockroaches — the person acquires the same fearful behaviour through modelling.

In behavioural terms, the phobia is a faulty behaviour pattern to be corrected in the present — typically through **systematic desensitisation** (a relaxation-plus-hierarchy technique based on reciprocal inhibition).

**The psychoanalyst's account**

Psychodynamic (psychoanalytic) therapy holds that **intrapsychic conflicts** — conflicts present within the psyche — are the source of psychological problems, and that these conflicts arise from **unfulfilled desires of childhood and unresolved childhood fears**. A psychoanalyst would therefore expl

Process	What it means	Example
Attention	You must actually pay attention to the model and the behaviour. Distraction kills learning.	You cannot learn a dance step if you are looking at your phone while the instructor demonstrates.
Retention	You must be able to remember what you observed. This usually involves mentally rehearsing or forming a verbal description.	You repeat the steps in your head: "left foot forward, then right foot to the side…"
Reproduction	You must have the physical and mental ability to perform the behaviour.	You cannot learn to do a backflip by watching if you lack the strength and coordination to actually do one.
Motivation	You must have a reason to perform the behaviour. This is where vicarious reinforcement matters most.	You are more likely to copy a behaviour if you saw the model get rewarded for it (e.g., a classmate who studied hard got an A). You are less likely if you saw them get punished (e.g., a classmate who cheated got caught).

Q.How would a social learning theorist account for a phobic fear of lizards/cockroaches? How would a psychoanalyst account for the same phobia?

Concept understanding — Observational Learning

Observational Learning: Learning by Watching Others

The Precise Statement

The Four Key Processes

The Famous Experiment: The Bobo Doll …

Q.How would a social learning theorist account for a phobic fear of lizards/cockroaches? How would a psychoanalyst account for the same phobia?

🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days

Unlock everything free for 14 days