Q.Suppose that pH of monobasic and dibasic acid is the same. Does this mean that the molar concentrations of both acids are identical ?
Step 1. pH depends only on [H+] (or, more precisely, [H3O+]) -- -- it says nothing directly about how many moles of ACID were originally dissolved to produce that [H+].
Step 2. A monobasic acid HA can release at most one H+ per molecule; a dibasic acid H2B can, in principle, release up to two H+ per molecule (though typically the second ionization is much weaker than the first).
Step 3. Because of this, a dibasic acid could reach the SAME [H+] as a monobasic acid while starting from a lower molar concentration, since each of its molecules potentially contributes more H+.
Step 4. Separately, the two acids are almost certainly not equally strong (their Ka values, and hence their degrees of dissociation at a given concentration, will typically differ) -- so even restricting to their FIRST ionization step alone, matching [H+] does not require matching molar concentration.
Step 5. Both factors -- the different maximum H+ yield per molecule, and generally different Ka values -- mean that identical pH for a monobasic and a dibasic acid does not imply identical molar concentrations of the two acids.
No -- equal pH only means equal [H+]; it does not fix the molar concentration, because a dibasic acid can supply up to two H+ per molecule and the two acids will generally have different dissociation constants.
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.