Q.State the Chromosomal Theory of Inheritance proposed by Walter Sutton and Theodor Boveri. What parallel behaviour of chromosomes and Mendelian factors during meiosis led them to propose this theory?
Concept understanding — Chromosomal Theory of Inheritance
The Chromosomal Theory of Inheritance states that Mendel's hereditary factors (genes) occupy specific, fixed positions (loci) on chromosomes, and it is the physical behaviour of chromosomes during cell division that carries this hereditary information from one generation to the next. The theory was built up gradually: Wilhelm Roux (1883) first suggested chromosomes might transmit heredity; Montgomery (1901) showed chromosomes occur as distinct pairs and that maternal and paternal chromosomes pair specifically with each other at meiosis; Boveri (1902) provided strong support that chromosomes carry genetic determiners; and Sutton (1902), independently, recognised the exact parallel between chromosome behaviour and Mendelian factor behaviour during gamete formation. Sutton and Boveri jointly proposed the formal theory in 1903. Its key claims are that somatic cells carry two homologous sets of chromosomes (one maternal, one paternal) derived from the zygote by mitosis; that each chromosome keeps a stable identity across the organism's life; that each chromosome carries a specific set of genes; and that chromosome movements during meiosis directly explain Mendel's laws of segregation and independent assortment. The theory remained debated until T.H. Morgan's 1910 work on Drosophila eye colour proved that a specific visible trait (red vs white eyes) is inherited strictly along with the X chromosome, giving the theory its decisive experimental confirmation and establishing the phenomenon of sex linkage.
Sutton and Boveri's Chromosomal Theory: Mendelian factors (genes) are located on chromosomes, based on the parallel behaviour of chromosomes and factors during meiosis.
Genes lie on chromosomes; chromosomes pair, segregate and assort independently during meiosis exactly as Mendelian factors do.
Step 1. Sutton and Boveri (c. 1902) proposed that Mendel's abstract hereditary factors (genes) are physically located on chromosomes.
Step 2. Parallel 1 — Mendelian factors occur in pairs; chromosomes occur as homologous pairs in a diploid cell.
Step 3. Parallel 2 — the two factors of a pair segregate during gamete formation (Law of Segregation); the two homologous chromosomes of a pair separate at anaphase I of meiosis.
Step 4. Parallel 3 — different factor pairs assort independently (Law of Independent Assortment); different homologous chromosome pairs orient independently at metaphase I.
Step 5. Parallel 4 — fertilisation restores the paired condition of factors in the zygote; fusion of haploid gametes restores the diploid, paired condition of chromosomes.
The exact parallel between chromosome behaviour (pairing, segregation, independent assortment, restoration at fertilisation) and Mendelian factor behaviour led Sutton and Boveri to propose that genes are carried on chromosomes.
List the four specific parallels (occurrence in pairs, segregation, independent assortment, restoration at fertilisation) between chromosome behaviour and Mendelian factor behaviour.
- Stating only that 'genes are on chromosomes' without explaining the observed parallel behaviour that led to the theory.
- Omitting that this was initially a theoretical/observational parallel, later confirmed experimentally by Morgan (see Q3).
- CBSE 2026Set SEM31 markMCQQ.Match Column-I with Column-II and select the correct option : Column-I : i) Telocentric chromosome ii) Acrocentric chromosome iii) Submetacentric chromosome iv) Metacentric chromosome ; Column-II : a) V shaped b) I shaped c) J shaped d) L shaped.(a) i-a, ii-b, iii-c, iv-d(b) i-b, ii-a, iii-d, iv-c(c) i-d, ii-c, iii-b, iv-a(d) i-d, ii-a, iii-b, iv-c
›Reveal solutionSolution
Chromosome shape depends on centromere position: metacentric = V-shaped, submetacentric = L-shaped, acrocentric = J-shaped, telocentric = I/rod-shaped. Among the given options, (c) is the one that correctly anchors metacentric → V-shaped (iv-a) and acrocentric → J-shaped (ii-c).
Standard classification by centromere position (as they appear when pulled at anaphase):
- Metacentric (centromere in the middle, equal arms) → V-shaped.
- Submetacentric (centromere slightly off-centre, unequal arms) → L-shaped.
- Acrocentric (centromere near one end, one very short arm) → J-shaped.
- Telocentric (centromere terminal, single arm) → I / rod-shaped.
Using the Column-II codes (a = V, b = I, c = J, d = L), option (c) uniquely places metacentric = V-shaped (iv-a) and acrocentric = J-shaped (ii-c) — the two most unambiguous matches — and it is the only option carrying metacentric → V-shaped, which is the anchor fact. Hence (c) is the intended key.
(Honesty note: the four options do not contain a fully textbook-perfect permutation; option (c) is selected as the best/intended match because it correctly places the definitive metacentric = V-shaped pairing, on which the key is anchored.)
Based on NCERT/CBSE Class 12 Biology cytogenetics (chromosome morphology).
✓Final answer(c) i-d, ii-c, iii-b, iv-a (anchored on metacentric = V-shaped, acrocentric = J-shaped).
- CBSE 2024Set E1 markMCQQ.Who propounded the chromosomal theory of inheritance?(a) Mendel(b) Sutton and Boveri(c) Morgan(d) Henking
›Reveal solutionSolution
Walter Sutton and Theodor Boveri proposed the chromosomal theory of inheritance.
Around 1902, Walter Sutton and Theodor Boveri independently recognised that the behaviour of chromosomes during meiosis exactly parallels the behaviour of Mendel's factors:
-
Chromosomes (like factors) occur in pairs and segregate during gamete formation, then combine at fertilisation.
-
They united this chromosome movement with Mendelian genetics in the chromosomal theory of inheritance.
-
(Mendel gave the laws of inheritance; Morgan later provided experimental proof using Drosophila; Henking discovered the X-body.)
✓Final answer(b) Sutton and Boveri.
-
- CBSE 2023Set A1 markMCQQ.Who give chromosomal theory of inheritance?(a) Robert Hook(b) Greger John Mendel(c) Sutton and Boveri(d) M. H. Swaminathan
›Reveal solutionSolution
Sutton and Boveri (1902) independently noted the parallel behaviour of chromosomes and Mendelian factors, giving the chromosomal theory of inheritance.
Walter Sutton and Theodor Boveri observed that the behaviour of chromosomes during meiosis (segregation and independent assortment) paralleled the behaviour of Mendel's factors (genes) — chromosomes occur in pairs, segregate during gamete formation, and are restored on fertilisation, exactly as Mendelian factors do. This led them to propose that genes are located on chromosomes — the chromosomal theory of inheritance. Robert Hooke discovered cells; Mendel gave the laws of inheritance; M.S. Swaminathan is known for the Green Revolution in India.
✓Final answer(c) Sutton and Boveri.
- CBSE 2021Set NC1 markQ.Who proposed the chromosomal theory of inheritance?
›Reveal solutionSolution
The chromosomal theory of inheritance, linking Mendel's factors (genes) to the physical behaviour of chromosomes during meiosis, was proposed by Sutton and Boveri and experimentally validated by T.H. Morgan.
The chromosomal theory of inheritance
After the rediscovery of Mendel's laws in 1900, cytologists noticed striking parallels between the behaviour of Mendel's "factors" (genes) during inheritance and the behaviour of chromosomes during meiosis (e.g., chromosomes occur in pairs, segregate during meiosis, and are transmitted to offspring in a manner paralleling Mendel's law of segregation and independent assortment).
Walter Sutton and Theodor Boveri, working independently around 1902, put these observations together and proposed the Chromosomal Theory of Inheritance, stating that genes are located on chromosomes and that it is the chromosomes (as carriers of genes) that undergo segregation and independent assortment during meiosis, thereby explaining Mendelian inheritance at a physical/cellular level.
This theory was later experimentally confirmed by Thomas Hunt Morgan and his colleagues through breeding experiments and studies of linkage in the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster, which provided direct evidence correlating specific genes with specific chromosomes (particularly the X chromosome).
✓Final answerThe chromosomal theory of inheritance was proposed by Sutton and Boveri (1902).
- CBSE 2020Set HE8241 markQ.Fill in the blank: Chromosomal theory of inheritance is given by ______ and Theodore Boveri.
›Reveal solutionSolution
The blank is Walter Sutton; Sutton and Boveri together proposed that chromosomes are the physical carriers of Mendelian factors (genes).
After the rediscovery of Mendel's work in 1900, cytologists noticed a striking parallel: chromosomes, like Mendelian 'factors', occur in pairs, segregate during meiosis (so that each gamete gets one member of a pair), and the pairs assort independently of each other. Working independently but publishing around the same time, Walter Sutton (an American cytologist) and Theodore Boveri (a German biologist) integrated these cytological observations with Mendelian principles and proposed that chromosomes are the vehicles of hereditary information — the genes are located on chromosomes. This became known as the Chromosomal Theory of Inheritance.
This theory was later experimentally confirmed by Thomas Hunt Morgan's work on sex-linked inheritance in Drosophila.
✓Final answerWalter Sutton — the Chromosomal Theory of Inheritance (Sutton and Boveri, 1902).
- CBSE 2019Set ANNUAL1 markQ.What is the function of centromere?
›Reveal solutionSolution
The centromere joins the sister chromatids and carries the kinetochore for spindle-fibre attachment, ensuring correct chromosome segregation during mitosis/meiosis.
The centromere is the constricted (primary constriction) region of a chromosome where the two sister chromatids are held together. Its functions:
-
It keeps the sister chromatids joined until they are separated during cell division.
-
It bears a disc-shaped protein structure, the kinetochore, to which the spindle fibres (microtubules) attach.
-
Through this attachment it enables the chromosomes to be moved and pulled apart correctly, ensuring that each daughter cell receives an equal, complete set of chromosomes during mitosis and meiosis.
✓Final answerThe centromere holds the sister chromatids together and provides the kinetochore for spindle-fibre attachment, ensuring proper segregation of chromosomes to the daughter cells during cell division.
-
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.