Q.How can you explain higher stability of BCl3 as compared to TlCl3?
Step 1 - Boron: no inert pair effect
Boron has configuration with no intervening d or f electrons; it forms by using all three valence electrons in bonding ( hybridisation), and this state is fully stable - there is essentially no inert pair effect at boron's small size/low period.
Step 2 - Thallium: strong inert pair effect
Thallium, a much heavier group 13 element (), shows a pronounced inert pair effect: poor shielding by the filled and subshells means the electron pair is held close to the nucleus and is reluctant to participate in bond formation.
Step 3 - Consequence for TlCl3
Consequently (using only the single electron) is the thermodynamically more stable oxidation state for thallium, while compounds such as are strong oxidising agents that are comparatively unstable and decompose, releasing chlorine and going to the more stable :
Step 4 - Comparison
Hence (boron fully using all 3 valence electrons, no inert pair effect) is markedly more stable than (thallium's pair resisting participation, +3 state disfavoured).
BCl3 is fully stable because boron shows no inert pair effect and uses all 3 valence electrons in bonding. TlCl3 is comparatively unstable because Tl's 6s2 pair resists bonding (inert pair effect), favouring Tl+1; TlCl3 readily decomposes, TlCl3 -> TlCl + Cl2.
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.