Skip to content
Question

Q.Describe Bernier’s description of land ownership in India and also describe its influence on Western theorists from 18th century onwards.

(OR)
Describe the experiences of Al-Biruni in the Indian Subcontinent.
CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2019Subjective· 8mImportance★★★★★
🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Part (a): Bernier held that the Mughal state owned all land, which he blamed for agricultural ruin and the absence of a middle class; contrasted with Europe, this shaped Western theories of Oriental Despotism and Marx's Asiatic Mode of Production.

Part (b): Al-Biruni learned Sanskrit and studied Indian texts, describing India's religion, sciences and caste system in his Kitab-ul-Hind while noting the barriers of language, unfamiliar beliefs and caste.

Part (a)

Francois Bernier was a French physician and philosopher who spent about twelve years in the Mughal Empire (1656-1668) and wrote Travels in the Mughal Empire, comparing India with contemporary Europe - usually to India's disadvantage.

His description of land ownership:

  • Bernier's central claim was that there was no private property in land in India: the emperor owned all the land and merely assigned it temporarily to his nobles (the jagirdars), who were revenue-collectors, not owners.
  • He argued that this had ruinous effects. Because holders had no secure or hereditary right and could be transferred at will, they had no incentive to invest in improving the land; instead they extracted as much as possible from the peasants. The result, he said, was neglected agriculture, oppressed and impoverished peasants, and the absence of a stable, prosperous 'middling' class such as existed in Europe.
  • He famously described the Mughal emperor as the "king of beggars and barbarians," ruling over ruined provinces - a picture drawn by contrasting India with the European system of private landholding.

Its influence on Western theorists:

  • Bernier's account was widely read and became a major source for European ideas about Asia. Montesquieu, in The Spirit of the Laws (1748), drew on it to develop the theory of 'Oriental Despotism' - the notion that Asian rulers exercised absolute, arbitrary power over subjects who owned no property and therefore had no rights.
  • In the nineteenth century, Karl Marx used the same idea in his concept of the 'Asiatic Mode of Production', in which the state controlled and owned land, surplus was appropriated by a despotic state, private property was absent, and society was therefore static. …

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.