Assertion (A) : Aromatic primary amines cannot be prepared by Gabriel phthalimide synthesis. Reason (R) : Gabr

Question

Q. Assertion (A) : Aromatic primary amines cannot be prepared by Gabriel phthalimide synthesis. Reason (R) : Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is used for the preparation of primary aliphatic amines. Options : (A) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true and Reason (R) is the correct explanation of the Assertion (A). (B) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true, but Reason (R) is not the correct explanation of the Assertion (A). (C) Assertion (A) is true, but Reason (R) is false. (D) Assertion (A) is false, but Reason (R) is true.

CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2026MCQ· 1mImportance★★★★★

🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Concept understanding — Gabriel Phthalimide Limitation

The Gabriel Phthalimide Limitation – First Principles

Imagine you want to make a primary amine ( $R-NH_2$ ) from an alkyl halide ( $R-X$ ). The obvious idea is to just let ammonia ( $NH_3$ ) attack the halide. But ammonia is a nucleophile and also a base — it will keep reacting. The product amine is even more nucleophilic than ammonia, so it attacks another alkyl halide molecule, giving a secondary amine ( $R_2NH$ ), then tertiary ( $R_3N$ ), and finally a quaternary ammonium salt ( $R_4N^+$ ). You end up with a messy mixture.

The Gabriel synthesis was invented to solve this: it gives only the primary amine, cleanly. But it has a hard limit.

The Intuition: Why the Gabriel Method Works (and Where It Breaks)

The trick is to use phthalimide — a molecule with two carbonyl groups flanking an $N-H$ bond. The $N-H$ is acidic enough to be deprotonated by a mild base (like $KOH$ or $K_2CO_3$ ), giving a phthalimide anion. This anion is a great nucleophile but a terrible base — it won't deprotonate the alkyl halide or cause elimination. It attacks the alkyl halide in an $S_N2$ reaction, forming an $N$ -alkylphthalimide.

Then you hydrolyse (or use hydrazine) to break the two amide bonds, releasing the primary amine and regenerating phthalic acid.

Note

The key limitation is $S_N2$ reactivity. The phthalimide anion is bulky and not very nucleophilic. It can only attack primary alkyl halides (or very reactive secondary ones like allyl/benzyl halides). Tertiary halides? They undergo elimination instead of substitution. Secondary halides? Very slow, often give poor yields.

The Precise Statement of the Limitation

Gabriel phthalimide synthesis fails for alkyl halides that are sterically hindered or prone to elimination. Specifically:

Tertiary alkyl halides ( $R_3C-X$ ) do not react — they undergo $E2$ elimination instead of $S_N2$ substitution.

Secondary alkyl halides ( $R_2CH-X$ ) react very slowly, if at all, and yields are poor.

Aryl halides (like chlorobenzene) do not react because $S_N2$ on an $sp^2$ carbon is impossible.

Alkyl halides with bulky groups near the reaction centre (neopentyl, etc.) also fail.

Watch out

A common mistake: students think the limitation is about the hydrolysis step. No — the limitation is entirely in the alkylation step. The phthalimide anion simply cannot force an $S_N2$ reaction on a hindered carbon.

Why This Matters for Exams

You'll be asked to identify which alkyl halides cannot be used in the Gabriel synthesis. The answer is always: tertiary halides, most secondary halides, and aryl halides. For example:

Alkyl Halide	Works?	Reason
$CH_3CH_2CH_2Br$	Yes	Primary, unhindered
$(CH_3)_2CHBr$	Poor	Secondary, slow $S_N2$
$(CH_3)_3CBr$	No	Tertiary — elimination dominates
$C_6H_5Br$	No	Aryl — $S_N2$ impossible on $sp^2$ carbon
$CH_2=CHCH_2Br$	Yes	Allylic — very reactive $S_N2$

Important

The Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is a reliable method only for preparing primary amines from primary alkyl halides (or very reactive secondary ones). For tertiary amines or hindered substrates, you need alternative methods (like reduction of nitriles or amides).

The Deeper Reason (For the Curious) …

Why this formula?

Gabriel Phthalimide Limitation — Why It Exists

The Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is a classic method to prepare primary amines ( $\text{R-NH}_2$ ) from alkyl halides. However, it has a critical limitation: it fails with secondary and tertiary alkyl halides (and also with aryl halides). Let's understand why this happens — the reasoning is rooted in reaction mechanism and steric hindrance.

1. The Key Reaction Steps (Brief Recap)

The synthesis proceeds in two main steps:

Formation of potassium phthalimide Phthalimide ( $\text{C}_6\text{H}_4(\text{CO})_2\text{NH}$ ) is treated with alcoholic KOH to give the potassium salt:

\text{C}_6\text{H}_4(\text{CO})_2\text{NH} + \text{KOH} \rightarrow \text{C}_6\text{H}_4(\text{CO})_2\text{N}^- \text{K}^+ + \text{H}_2\text{O}

N-alkylation (the critical step) The phthalimide anion acts as a nucleophile and attacks an alkyl halide ( $\text{R-X}$ ) via an $\text{S}_\text{N}2$ mechanism:

\text{C}_6\text{H}_4(\text{CO})_2\text{N}^- + \text{R-X} \rightarrow \text{C}_6\text{H}_4(\text{CO})_2\text{N-R} + \text{X}^-

Hydrolysis to release the primary amine.

2. Why the Limitation Exists — The $\text{S}_\text{N}2$ Bottleneck

The key formula that governs the success of this reaction is the rate law for $\text{S}_\text{N}2$ :

\text{Rate} = k[\text{Nucleophile}][\text{Alkyl halide}]

For the Gabriel synthesis, the nucleophile is the phthalimide anion — a bulky, planar, and resonance-stabilized species. This has two consequences:

A. Steric Hindrance at the Electrophilic Carbon

In an $\text{S}_\text{N}2$ reaction, the nucleophile must approach the backside of the carbon bearing the leaving group.
Primary alkyl halides ( $\text{RCH}_2\text{X}$ ) have a small, unhindered carbon — the nucleophile can easily attack.
Secondary alkyl halides ( $\text{R}_2\text{CHX}$ ) have moderate steric hindrance — the bulky phthalimide anion struggles to approach.
Tertiary alkyl halides ( $\text{R}_3\text{CX}$ ) are severely hindered — the backside is blocked by three alkyl groups. The $\text{S}_\text{N}2$ transition state is impossible to achieve.

B. The $\text{S}_\text{N}2$ Transition State Geometry

The $\text{S}_\text{N}2$ transition state requires a linear arrangement of nucleophile, carbon, and leaving group:

\text{Nu}^- \cdots \text{C} \cdots \text{X}

For the phthalimide anion, this linear approach is sterically impossible when the carbon is tertiary (and difficult for secondary). The bulky phthalimide group cannot fit into the crowded transition state.

3. What Happens Instead? — Elimination Dominates

When a secondary or tertiary alkyl halide is used, the strongly basic phthalimide anion does not perform $\text{S}_\text{N}2$ — it instead acts as a base and promotes $\text{E}2$ elimination:

\text{R}_3\text{C-X} + \text{Phth}^- \rightarrow \text{Alkene} + \text{H-Phth} + \text{X}^-

This is because: …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Gabriel phthalimide synthesis fails for aromatic primary amines because aryl halides do not undergo nucleophilic substitution under the reaction conditions. The reason correctly states that the method is for aliphatic amines, but it does not explain why aromatic amines fail — so both statements are true, but the reason is not the correct explanation.

The key here is to understand why Gabriel phthalimide synthesis works for some amines and not others — and that comes down to the chemistry of the nucleophilic substitution step.

Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is a two-step method: first, phthalimide is treated with alcoholic KOH to form the potassium salt of phthalimide. This salt is a strong nucleophile. In the second step, it attacks an alkyl halide ( $R-X$ ) in an $S_N2$ reaction, giving an N-alkylphthalimide. Finally, hydrolysis (or hydrazinolysis) liberates the primary amine.

The critical step is the $S_N2$ attack. For this to happen, the carbon bearing the halogen must be able to undergo backside attack — it must be sp³-hybridised and not too sterically hindered. Aryl halides (like chlorobenzene) have the halogen attached directly to an sp² carbon of the benzene ring. Such carbons do not undergo $S_N2$ reactions because the p-orbitals of the double bond block the backside approach, and the C–X bond has partial double-bond character due to resonance.

So the assertion is true: you cannot prepare aromatic primary amines (like aniline) this way. The reason is also true: Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is indeed used for aliphatic primary amines. But the reason does not explain why aromatic amines fail — it merely states what the method is used for. The actual explanation lies in the reactivity of aryl halides, not in the classification of the product.

Let’s walk through the logic step by step.

Understand the assertion.

Assertion (A) says aromatic primary amines cannot be prepared by Gabriel phthalimide synthesis. This is correct. If you try to react potassium phthalimide with chlorobenzene, no reaction occurs under normal conditions. Even if you force the reaction (high temperature, catalyst), the product is not aniline — you get side products.
Understand the reason.

Reason (R) says Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is used for the preparation of primary aliphatic amines. This is also correct. The classic examples are the preparation of ethylamine, benzylamine, etc. from their respective alkyl halides.
Check if (R) explains (A). …

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

Same / Similar Concept — real previous-year questions on the same or a closely similar concept, not this exact question.

CBSE 2026Set 56/3/11 markMCQ
$Q. Assertion (A) : Aromatic primary amines cannot be prepared by Gabriel phthalimide synthesis. Reason (R) : Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is used for the preparation of primary aliphatic amines. Options : (A) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true and Reason (R) is the correct explanation of the Assertion (A). (B) Both Assertion (A) and Reason (R) are true, but Reason (R) is not the correct explanation of the Assertion (A). (C) Assertion (A) is true, but Reason (R) is false. (D) Assertion (A) is false, but Reason (R) is true.$
›Reveal solutionSolution
Gabriel phthalimide synthesis fails for aromatic primary amines because aryl halides do not undergo nucleophilic substitution under the reaction conditions. The reason correctly states that the method is for aliphatic amines, but it does not explain why aromatic amines fail — so both statements are true, but the reason is not the correct explanation.

The key here is to understand why Gabriel phthalimide synthesis works for some amines and not others — and that comes down to the chemistry of the nucleophilic substitution step.

Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is a two-step method: first, phthalimide is treated with alcoholic KOH to form the potassium salt of phthalimide. This salt is a strong nucleophile. In the second step, it attacks an alkyl halide ( $R-X$ ) in an $S_N2$ reaction, giving an N-alkylphthalimide. Finally, hydrolysis (or hydrazinolysis) liberates the primary amine.

The critical step is the $S_N2$ attack. For this to happen, the carbon bearing the halogen must be able to undergo backside attack — it must be sp³-hybridised and not too sterically hindered. Aryl halides (like chlorobenzene) have the halogen attached directly to an sp² carbon of the benzene ring. Such carbons do not undergo $S_N2$ reactions because the p-orbitals of the double bond block the backside approach, and the C–X bond has partial double-bond character due to resonance.

So the assertion is true: you cannot prepare aromatic primary amines (like aniline) this way. The reason is also true: Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is indeed used for aliphatic primary amines. But the reason does not explain why aromatic amines fail — it merely states what the method is used for. The actual explanation lies in the reactivity of aryl halides, not in the classification of the product.

Let’s walk through the logic step by step.

Understand the assertion.

Assertion (A) says aromatic primary amines cannot be prepared by Gabriel phthalimide synthesis. This is correct. If you try to react potassium phthalimide with chlorobenzene, no reaction occurs under normal conditions. Even if you force the reaction (high temperature, catalyst), the product is not aniline — you get side products.

Understand the reason.

Reason (R) says Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is used for the preparation of primary aliphatic amines. This is also correct. The classic examples are the preparation of ethylamine, benzylamine, etc. from their respective alkyl halides.

Check if (R) explains (A). …
Start your 14-day free trial to see the full solution →
CBSE 2026Set 56/2/11 markMCQ
$Q. Assertion (A) : Aromatic primary amines can be prepared by Gabriel Phthalimide synthesis. Reason (R) : Aryl halides do not undergo nucleophilic substitution with the anion formed by phthalimide.$
›Reveal solutionSolution
Gabriel phthalimide synthesis works only for aliphatic primary amines because aryl halides resist nucleophilic substitution. Assertion is false, Reason is true.

Understanding Gabriel Phthalimide Synthesis

The Gabriel synthesis is a classic method for preparing primary amines. The strategy is elegant: phthalimide (with $\mathrm{p}K_\mathrm{a} \approx 9$ ) is deprotonated by base to form a nucleophilic anion, which then attacks an alkyl halide in an $\mathrm{S_N2}$ displacement. Hydrolysis of the resulting N-alkylphthalimide releases the primary amine.

The entire method hinges on a successful nucleophilic substitution step. That's where the limitation appears.

Why Aryl Halides Don't Cooperate

Aryl halides—compounds where a halogen is directly bonded to a benzene ring—are notoriously unreactive toward nucleophilic substitution under normal conditions. Three factors conspire against the reaction:

Partial double-bond character: The lone pairs on the halogen overlap with the aromatic $\pi$ -system, giving the C–X bond some double-bond character. This strengthens the bond and makes it harder to break.

$\mathrm{S_N2}$ geometry is impossible: An $\mathrm{S_N2}$ mechanism requires backside attack at the carbon bearing the leaving group. In an aryl halide, that carbon is $sp^2$ -hybridized and embedded in a planar ring—there's no accessible backside. The nucleophile would have to attack through the ring itself.

$\mathrm{S_N1}$ is prohibitively unfavorable: Heterolytic cleavage would produce a phenyl cation, an extraordinarily unstable species. The empty $p$ -orbital would be orthogonal to the aromatic $\pi$ -system, offering no stabilization. The activation energy is far too high.

Watch out

A common mistake is assuming that because aryl halides contain a halogen, they behave like alkyl halides. The aromatic ring fundamentally changes the reactivity—standard nucleophilic substitutions simply don't occur.

Evaluating the Statements

Assertion (A): Claims aromatic primary amines can be prepared by Gabriel synthesis.

This is false. The synthesis requires an alkyl halide (or similar electrophile) that undergoes $\mathrm{S_N2}$ substitution with the phthalimide anion. Since aryl halides don't participate in this substitution, you cannot use Gabriel synthesis to make aniline or other aromatic primary amines. …
Start your 14-day free trial to see the full solution →
CBSE 2026Set ANNUAL1 markMCQ
$Q. Regarding Gabriel synthesis for amines, which of the following statements is correct?$
(a) All types of amines can be synthesized
(b) Only aromatic amines can be synthesized
(c) Only aliphatic amines can be synthesized
(d) Only aliphatic primary amines can be synthesized
›Reveal solutionSolution
Gabriel phthalimide synthesis works only through nucleophilic substitution of an alkyl halide, so it gives only aliphatic primary amines — option (D).

In the Gabriel phthalimide synthesis, phthalimide is treated with $KOH$ to give potassium phthalimide, whose nitrogen then displaces the halogen of an alkyl halide ( $S_N2$ ). Alkaline hydrolysis of the resulting $N$ -alkylphthalimide finally releases a primary amine.

Because the nitrogen ends up bonded to only one alkyl group, the product is always a primary amine (no secondary/tertiary amines). …
Start your 14-day free trial to see the full solution →
CBSE 2025Set ANNUAL1 mark
$Q. Why cannot aromatic primary amines be prepared by Gabriel phthalimide synthesis?$
›Reveal solutionSolution
Gabriel synthesis's first (and essential) step is an SN2 attack of phthalimide anion on the alkyl/aryl halide; aryl halides are inert to SN2 for structural and electronic reasons, so aromatic primary amines cannot be made this way.

The Gabriel phthalimide synthesis makes a primary amine in two steps: (1) potassium phthalimide is alkylated by an alkyl halide, $R-X$ , through a nucleophilic substitution (SN2) in which the phthalimide nitrogen's lone pair (as its anion) displaces the halide ion; (2) the resulting N-alkylphthalimide is then hydrolysed (or treated with hydrazine) to liberate the primary amine $R-NH_2$ .

Step (1) requires the halide-bearing carbon to be accessible to backside nucleophilic attack, i.e. it must be a genuine SN2-reactive alkyl halide. Aryl halides ( $Ar-X$ ) cannot undergo this step, because:

the halogen-bearing carbon is $sp^2$ -hybridised and lies in the plane of the aromatic ring, so there is no accessible backside for the nucleophile to attack (the ring itself blocks it);

the C–X bond has partial double-bond character (the halogen's lone pair is delocalised into the ring by resonance), making it shorter and stronger than a normal C–X single bond, and a poorer leaving group; …
Start your 14-day free trial to see the full solution →
CBSE 2020Set NC1 mark
$Q. Why aromatic primary amines cannot be prepared by Gabriel phthalimide synthesis?$
›Reveal solutionSolution
Gabriel phthalimide synthesis is an $S_N2$ displacement on an alkyl halide by phthalimide anion; aryl halides are essentially unreactive toward this mechanism, so the method is limited to aliphatic primary amines.

Gabriel synthesis (as normally used, for aliphatic amines): Potassium phthalimide's nitrogen anion is a good nucleophile that displaces a halide from an alkyl halide in an $S_N2$ reaction, giving N-alkylphthalimide, which is then hydrolysed (or hydrazinolysed) to liberate the primary amine and phthalhydrazide:

$\text{Phthalimide}^{-}K^{+} + R\text{–X} \longrightarrow N\text{-alkylphthalimide} \xrightarrow{H_3O^{+}/OH^{-}} R\text{–}NH_2$

Why it fails for aromatic amines. To make an arylamine (e.g. aniline) this way, one would need to react phthalimide anion with an aryl halide (e.g. chlorobenzene) by the same $S_N2$ mechanism. But aryl halides do not undergo nucleophilic substitution under these conditions because:

the carbon–halogen bond in an aryl halide has partial double-bond character (from resonance/conjugation of the halogen lone pair with the ring), making it shorter and stronger than a normal C–X bond; …
Start your 14-day free trial to see the full solution →

🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days

Unlock everything free for 14 days