Skip to content
Question

Q.Which of the following summarizes the speaker's opinion about study?

(a) Childhood should be spent in experiential learning.
(b) Studying is better than playing.
(c) Studying is essential to the nation's progress.
(d) Studying leads to social reforms and progress. (Memories of Childhood)
CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2023MCQ· 1mImportance★★★★★
🔒 Locked · start free trial →

You're viewing a preview — the full solution, concept, methods & PYQ mapping are locked.

Start your 14-day free trial to unlock the full solution →

The chapter "Memories of Childhood" presents two distinct perspectives on study: one highlighting its oppressive nature when forced, and the other emphasizing its power as a tool for social reform and personal progress, particularly for marginalized communities.

"Memories of Childhood" comprises two autobiographical excerpts: "The Cutting of My Long Hair" by Zitkala-Sa and "We Too Are Human Beings" by Bama. Both narratives vividly portray the experiences of marginalized children within educational systems, but they offer different insights into the concept of "study." To understand the speaker's opinion about study, we must consider the perspectives presented in both parts.

Zitkala-Sa's account details her traumatic experience at a residential school designed to assimilate Native American children into Euro-American culture. For her, "study" in this context is not a joyful or enriching activity but a tool of oppression. She resists the rigid routines, the unfamiliar language, and the forced conformity, such as the cutting of her long hair, which strips her of her cultural identity. Her memories are filled with a longing for her mother's lap, her moccasins, and the freedom of her native life, where learning was likely more experiential and integrated with her culture and nature. Her narrative implicitly suggests that childhood should be a time of natural growth and cultural immersion, rather than forced, alienating instruction.

Note

Zitkala-Sa's narrative primarily focuses on the negative impact of a particular type of schooling and the loss of cultural identity, rather than offering a positive opinion about "study" itself. Her resistance highlights a preference for a different, more natural way of learning and living.

Bama's story, on the other hand, explores the harsh realities of caste discrimination she faced as a Dalit child. Initially, her journey home from school is filled with distractions and observations of the world around her – the street performers, the shops, the political meetings. This period of observation is a form of experiential learning, where she begins to grasp the social hierarchies and injustices. The pivotal moment comes when her elder brother, Annan, explains the indignity of untouchability and offers a solution. He tells her, "If you study with care, you can throw away all these indignities. Study and make progress. If you are always ahead in your lessons, people will come to you of their own accord and attach themselves to you. Work hard and learn."

Important

Annan's advice to Bama is a direct and explicit statement about the purpose and power of study. It frames education not just as personal advancement but as a means to challenge and overcome systemic social injustice.

Considering the options:

  • (a) Childhood should be spent in experiential learning. This idea resonates strongly with Zitkala-Sa's longing for her natural upbringing and Bama's initial observations of the world around her. Both narratives contrast the restrictive formal schooling with a more organic, experience-based way of learning. While this is a valid interpretation of a preferred mode of learning in childhood, it doesn't fully capture the explicit opinion about study as a tool for change. …

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.