Q.Why is chlorination of methane not possible in the dark?
Step 1. Methane's chlorination (CH4 + Cl2 gives CH3Cl + HCl, and onward to CH2Cl2, CHCl3, CCl4) is a free-radical SUBSTITUTION reaction.
Step 2. Its mechanism needs an initiation step in which the Cl-Cl bond is broken HOMOLYTICALLY (one electron to each chlorine atom) to generate two chlorine free radicals -- this homolysis specifically requires an external energy input, supplied as UV light or heat.
Step 3. In the dark, with neither light nor added heat, there is no way to homolyse Cl2 into radicals, so the initiation step -- and therefore the entire radical chain (propagation: Cl* + CH4 gives CH3* + HCl; CH3* + Cl2 gives CH3Cl + Cl*) -- never gets started.
Step 4. Without an initiating radical, methane and chlorine simply sit together unreacted, which is exactly why light (or heat) is essential and the reaction cannot proceed in the dark.
Chlorination of methane proceeds by a free-radical chain mechanism, and generating the very first Cl radical needs the energy of UV/sunlight (or heat) to homolyse Cl2 -- in the dark, with no such energy source, no radicals form and the reaction simply cannot begin.
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.