Q.Obtain the macroscopic form of Ohm's law from its microscopic form and discuss its limitations.
Step 1. Start from the microscopic form, , for a uniform conductor of length l and cross-sectional area A.
Step 2. Assuming the field is uniform along the wire, the potential difference across it is , so ; also, .
Step 3. Substituting both into gives , which rearranges to .
Step 4. The bracketed quantity depends only on the conductor's geometry and material, and is DEFINED as its resistance, (using ).
Step 5. This gives the macroscopic form of Ohm's law, -- the everyday relation between the terminal quantities V and I of a specific wire, as opposed to the microscopic relation between the FIELD quantities J and E at a point.
Step 6. Limitations: this macroscopic form silently assumes R is a fixed constant, independent of V, I, or temperature. It applies cleanly only to ohmic materials (straight-line I-V graph through the origin); non-ohmic devices (e.g. a diode, or a filament lamp that heats and changes resistance as more current flows) have no single constant R, so with one fixed R does not correctly describe them, even though the more fundamental microscopic form (with evaluated locally) remains valid.
Substituting and into the microscopic form gives with ; this macroscopic form is limited to ohmic materials with a genuinely constant R and breaks down for non-ohmic devices whose resistance itself varies with V, I or temperature.
Unlock everything free for 14 days
- Full step-by-step solutions
- Concept-first explanations
- Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.