Skip to content
Question

Q.A cell of internal resistance rr connected across an external resistance RR can supply maximum current when (A) R=rR = r (B) R>rR > r (C) R=r2R = \dfrac{r}{2} (D) R=0R = 0

CBSECBSE Class XII Board 2020MCQ· 1mImportance★★★★★
✓ Free question

Maximum current from a cell is limited by the total circuit resistance. Since current I=ER+rI = \frac{E}{R + r}, the current is largest when the denominator is smallest — that is, when R=0R = 0. The correct option is (D).

The key idea here is deceptively simple: a cell (or battery) has an internal resistance rr that is always present, like a small resistor hidden inside. When you connect an external resistor RR, the total resistance in the circuit is R+rR + r. The current that flows is given by Ohm’s law for the whole circuit:

I=ER+rI = \frac{E}{R + r}

where EE is the electromotive force (emf) of the cell — a fixed value for a given cell.

Now, the question asks: for what value of RR is this current maximum? Since EE is constant, II is maximum when the denominator R+rR + r is minimum. The smallest possible value of RR is zero (a short circuit). So the maximum current occurs when R=0R = 0.

Let’s walk through the reasoning step by step.

  1. Write the expression for current. For a cell of emf EE and internal resistance rr, connected to an external resistance RR, the total resistance in the circuit is R+rR + r. The current is:

I=ER+rI = \frac{E}{R + r}

  1. Identify the variable.

    EE and rr are fixed for a given cell. Only RR can be changed. So II is a function of RR alone.

  2. Maximise II by minimising the denominator.

    Since EE is positive and constant, II increases as R+rR + r decreases. The smallest possible value of RR is 00 (you cannot have negative resistance in a passive circuit). Therefore:

Imax=E0+r=ErI_{\text{max}} = \frac{E}{0 + r} = \frac{E}{r}

This is the short-circuit current of the cell.

  1. Check the options.
    • (A) R=rR = r gives I=E2rI = \frac{E}{2r}, which is half the maximum.
    • (B) R>rR > r gives an even smaller current.
    • (C) R=r/2R = r/2 gives I=E1.5rI = \frac{E}{1.5r}, still less than E/rE/r.
    • (D) R=0R = 0 gives I=E/rI = E/r, the maximum possible.
Watch out

A common mistake is to confuse maximum current with maximum power transfer. The maximum power transfer theorem states that maximum power is delivered to the load when R=rR = r. But here the question is about current, not power. For current, you want the smallest total resistance — which means R=0R = 0.

Tip

Think of it this way: the internal resistance rr is like a bottleneck inside the cell. No matter what you do outside, the current can never exceed E/rE/r. To get as close as possible to that limit, you must make the external resistance as small as possible — ideally zero.

✓Final answer

The correct option is (D) R=0R = 0.

Unlock everything free for 14 days

  • Full step-by-step solutions
  • Concept-first explanations
  • Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
  • PYQ mapping + timed mock tests

Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.