Q.Compare the following two conjugate bases and answer.

Only a carboxylic acid is acidic enough to release CO2 from NaHCO3, so effervescence identifies acetic acid.

Carboxylic acids are strong enough acids to decompose sodium bicarbonate, releasing carbon dioxide gas (brisk effervescence):

CH3COOH + NaHCO3 --> CH3COONa + H2O + CO2 (up-arrow)

…

The ortho -OH's strong -I effect plus H-bond-stabilised conjugate base make salicylic acid the strongest acid of the four.

Comparing substituted benzoic acids: an ortho- or para- electron-withdrawing group increases acidity (stabilises the carboxylate conjugate base), while an electron-donating group decreases acidity.

• Salicylic acid (o-OH): the $-OH$ group is strongly electron-withdrawing by induction at the ortho position (its resonance donation is largely used up in its own ring conjugation from that close a position), and the conjugate base is further stabilised by intramolecular hydrogen bonding — making salicylic acid distinctly MORE acidic than benzoic acid ($pK_a \approx 2.97$ vs $4.2$). …

Use NaHCO3: formic acid effervesces (CO2), formaldehyde does not.

Both formic acid (HCOOH) and formaldehyde (HCHO) contain a -CHO type group, so both reduce Tollen's reagent, Fehling's solution and Benedict's solution — these cannot distinguish them.

However, formic acid is a carboxylic acid, so it reacts with sodium bicarbonate to liberate CO2 with brisk effervescence:

HCOOH + NaHCO3 -> HCOONa + H2O + CO2

…

Both reduce Tollens'/Fehling's/Benedict's, so those cannot distinguish them; only NaHCO3 does (acid vs non-acid).

Formic acid (HCOOH) has both an acidic -COOH and a reducing -CHO-like character, while formaldehyde (HCHO) is only a reducing aldehyde. Therefore:

• Tollens' reagent: BOTH give silver mirror (both are reducing) - no distinction.
• Fehling's / Benedict's solution: BOTH reduce them (formic acid also reduces) - no distinction. …

Carboxylic acid strength is governed by how well the conjugate base's negative charge is stabilised: electron-donating alkyl groups (+I effect) destabilise the carboxylate and WEAKEN the acid, while electron-withdrawing groups (like $-Cl$, -I effect) stabilise the carboxylate and STRENGTHEN the acid.

Propanoic acid ($CH_3CH_2COOH$, $pK_a\approx4.87$) has the longest alkyl chain (strongest +I donation) and is the weakest of the four. Acetic acid ($CH_3COOH$, $pK_a\approx4.76$) has a shorter alkyl group, so is slightly stronger. Formic acid ($HCOOH$, $pK_a\approx3.75$) has NO alkyl group at all (just H), removing the destabilising +I effect entirely, making it noticeably stronger than acetic acid. Chloroacetic acid ($ClCH_2COOH$, $pK_a\approx2.86$) has a strongly electron-withdrawing $-Cl$ directly stabilising the carboxylate by i …