Q.Calculate the radius of the second Bohr orbit of the singly ionised helium ion He+ (Z=2), using the value of the first Bohr radius of hydrogen as 0.529 Å.
Concept understanding — Bohr Model — Orbit Radii
Combining Bohr's first postulate (electrostatic attraction supplies the centripetal force) with his second (quantized angular momentum, mevnrn=nh/2π) gives two simultaneous equations in the unknowns vn and rn for the nth allowed orbit. Solving them together yields the orbit-radius formula rn=πmeZe2n2h2ϵ0 -- the radius grows as the SQUARE of the principal quantum number n, meaning higher orbits are dramatically larger, not just slightly larger, than lower ones -- and the companion speed formula vn=2ϵ0hnZe2, showing the electron actually moves SLOWER in higher, larger orbits.
For hydrogen (Z=1), the n=1 radius works out to a special reference value, the Bohr radius a0=0.053 nm, so the general formula can be written compactly as rn=a0n2/Z for any hydrogen-like (single-electron) system with nuclear charge Z. This one formula is what makes it possible to directly compare orbit sizes across different values of n or Z -- for instance, showing that a singly ionized helium ion's first orbit (Z=2) is exactly half the size of hydrogen's first orbit (Z=1), or that a hydrogen atom's 8th orbit is sixteen times larger in area (four times larger in radius) than its 4th orbit.
rn=0.529n2/Z Å. For He+ (Z=2), n=2: r2=0.529×4/2=1.058 Å.
r2(He+)=1.058 Å =1.058×10−10 m.
Using rn=Z0.529n2 A˚ (Example 5) with Z=2 (He+) and n=2:
r2=20.529×22 A˚=20.529×4 A˚=1.058 A˚
r2(He+)=1.058 A˚=1.058×10−10 m.
Substitute Z=2 and n=2 directly into the scaled orbit-radius formula rn=0.529n2/Z Å.
- Using Z=1 by mistake (forgetting He+ has one proton more than hydrogen even after losing one electron).
- Forgetting to square n before dividing by Z.
- CBSE 2024Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.The relation between angular momentum (L) and radius (r) of an electron revolving in a Bohr-orbit is(a) L ∝ r(b) L ∝ r⁻¹(c) L ∝ r²(d) does not depend on radius.
›Reveal solutionSolution
From Bohr's two results, L=nh/2π∝n and rn∝n2, eliminating n gives the true relation L∝r — which is not literally one of the four options offered, so this needs an honest note rather than a forced pick.
In the Bohr model of the hydrogen-like atom, two standard results follow from the quantisation postulate and the Coulomb force providing centripetal force:
-
Bohr's angular-momentum quantisation: L=mvr=2πnh, so L∝n.
-
The orbit radius: balancing rmv2=r2kZe2 together with the quantisation condition gives rn=πmZe2n2h2ε0, so r∝n2.
Eliminating the quantum number n between these two: since r∝n2, we have n∝r, and since L∝n, substituting gives
L∝ri.e.L2∝r
This is the physically correct relationship — angular momentum grows only as the SQUARE ROOT of the orbit radius, not linearly, inversely, or as its square. None of the four printed choices (L∝r, L∝r⁻¹, L∝r², independent of r) is exactly this. Being honest about that mismatch rather than picking a wrong option with false confidence: if a single choice must be marked, (a) L ∝ r is the least-wrong pick only in the sense that it is also a directly increasing relationship (like the true r dependence), unlike the inverse or r² options — but the correct physics answer is L∝r.
✓Final answerCorrectly, L∝r (from L∝n and r∝n2). This does not exactly match any of the four printed options; among them, (a) is the closest in character (both increasing with r).
-
- CBSE 2023Set ANNUAL1 markMCQQ.The radius of eighth orbit of electron in H-atom will be more than that of fourth orbit by a factor of ______.(a) 2(b) 4(c) 8(d) 16
›Reveal solutionSolution
Bohr orbit radius scales as n2.
The radius of the nth Bohr orbit is rn=n2r1 (radius ∝n2). So
r4r8=(48)2=22=4
The eighth orbit's radius is 4 times the fourth orbit's radius.
✓Final answer4 — option (b).
🎓Unlock everything free for 14 days
- ✓Full step-by-step solutions
- ✓Concept-first explanations
- ✓Methods, shortcuts & mistakes
- ✓PYQ mapping + timed mock tests
Full access for 14 days. No credit card required.